Author: Vasiliki Michopoulou

  • What penalty provided for “Plagiarism” and for not promoting science?

    Plagiarism is the most common crime in Greek journalism that remains unpunished. What is plagiarism? According to the Greek dictionary compiled by Prof. Bambiniotis is “the appropriation of a foreign intellectual property.” In simple words: “I take someone else’s work and I present it as mine”.
    Sounds like theft? It is so, because plagiarism is theft, and a theft that hurts much more than a common one and an offence which often hurts much more than the theft of an object.

    OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
    OLYMPUS DIGITAL CAMERA
    In that way I’ve been offended too. Indeed, plagiarism – in the era of internet and the information revolution – is so easy.
    Often people forget that it is a crime and they are tempted to steal some information even if their real intention is just to do some research in order to write their own ideas. Anyway, it’s so simple: click, copy, click, paste and the ideas of another person appear in their document, without having done almost no effort. This is exactly what my Greek colleague “D” did. This plagiarism episode that affects me, causes at least surprise to the extent that can take a journalist’s audacity and non-professionalism. The worse is that the official Union of Greek Journalists showed elasticity and did not punish the guilty.
    The story is simple and very common. In my case, four years ago I traveled with a photographer from Greece to a central European country in order to meet a Greek Leading researcher. I returned having in my pocket a great interview from him which I wrote for the daily Greek newspaper I used to work then. Two years later I saw the same interview published with almost exactly the same phrases in another daily Greek newspaper by another journalist, with a different signature, that of my colleague “D”. I called him to get some answers but he denied everything. He claimed that he had also called the Greek scientist and he forced me in a provocative way to drag him to the disciplinary council of the Official Union of Greek Journalists in which we are both members. I did so, having the hope that the truth would be the winner but I was wrong because the “guilty” was acquitted. He managed to convince the majority of the members of the council that he was innocent of plagiarism. Obviously he took advantage of having some strong connections among the board members who supported him in a positive way.

    That’s why Greece will never have an official union of science journalists…

    I was very disappointed then and I felt absolutely sure that we will never set an official science journalist association in Greece. And I will explain that.My colleague “D” is not a scientist but for many years he has convinced his audience that he has the right to write about science. Why? Because science journalism doesn’t exist in Greece. Everybody pretends knowing and writing about everything and this is a real problem. Although, a few of the journalists happen to have a scientific background, the majority of them have not and they continue to write about science regardless to their own inexperience, like “D” does.
    In Greece, there isn’t a specific Union for Science Journalists, recognized by the official Union of Greek Journalists associations. But the most worryingly is that there isn’t a specific course for Science Journalism and Communication even at the Faculty of Mass Media Communication at the University. In other words, this Faculty “produces” journalists without specification and knowledge of Science communication.
    By observing all this situation I tried two years ago to mobilize some colleagues to set an official Greek Association of Science Journalist in order to be more organized and to build a strong bond as a union with EUSJA. I invited 21 colleagues who -as I believed- could understand and write about science in the media, some of them having also a scientific background. And this was not very easy. After a little research I found them and I called them to share my vision (it’s amazing that no one spent some of his precious time to meet me personally).
    Unfortunately among them was “D” who accepted my idea and he agreed to help me to set all together the science union. This Union of Greek Science Journalists was never set up and “D” used later this vision of mine as an argument against me after my complaint for his plagiarism to the disciplinary council of our official union. The fact is that he claimed that my action had something of revenge and that I was very angry because I couldn’t manage to set the union. The worst was that he created the impression to the members of the council that my whole motion to set up the new science union had a disruptive character for the existed official union of Greek journalists. This means that if you try to talk or write about science in Greece you are disruptive.

    And here comes the question: What penalty is provided for not promoting science?

    What penalty is provided for plagiarism? According to the law, heavy, mostly. Starting from 1-5 years in prison for simple offenses and go up to 10 years imprisonment for those who steal intellectual property by profession or habit. If you add to them and the high financial penalties provided for we will understand the extent of the seriousness, despite the fact that few people know it.
    And now, what penalty is provided for not promoting science? What penalty is provided for the weak mind and poor imagination of some people, which have become the “common currency” of popular journalism and doom a country to remain in the Middle Ages with plagiarism and without real science journalism?
    I need your answer.

  • It was the Salmonella typhoid which caused the Plague of Ancient Athens and not the Ebola virus

    The great Plague of Athens, the terrible epidemic that swept through the city state of Athens from 430 to 426 B.C. was the cause of death not only of many thousands ancient Athenians, including their leader Pericles, but also the cause of the decline of the most historic Democracy of the world.
    αρχείο λήψης (1)
    The cause of the Plague of Athens intrigued the global scientific community for a long time. Based on Thucydides’ descriptions scientists and historians had tried for years to offer theories about the underlying disease suggesting about 25 different possibilities.
    Among them there was the theory that the Ebola virus caused the Plague of Athens, according to Anthony Ramirez in an article published in New York Times in 1996, which was brought again in public recently.
    Ten years later, in 2006, Greek scientists provided the first scientific evidence regarding the Plague of Athens derived from analysis of DNA of skeletal material. Almost two and a half millenia after the historical event the Greek scientists discovered that the Plague which devastated the Athenian society of classical era was a particularly aggressive strain of Salmonella enterica Typhi.
    The discovery was made possible with the cooperation of Effie Baziotopoulou-Valavani, an archaeologist who found a mass grave of ancient Athenians who were apparently victims of the Plague, Dr. Manolis Papagrigorakis, Professor of Orthodontics in University of Athens Dental School, who collected and stored the skeletal material, his collaborator orthodontist Dr. Philip Synodinou and Dr. Christos Yapijakis, Professor of Neurogenetics in University of Athens Medical School, who performed the molecular analysis and identified the DNA of the pathogen.
    Scientific research revealed that the cause of the Plague of Athens was typhoid fever. As Professor Yapijakis explains:”From a mass grave of over 150 people which was discovered in the ancient cemetery of Athens, Kerameikos, archaeologically documented to belong in the period of the Plague, we collected and examined skeletal material. We specifically tested pulp DNA from teeth of three different skulls found in the mass grave, because the enamel is a very resiliant substance and offers excellent protection to the DNA material within the pulp.We hypothesized that the infectious pathogen that caused bacteremia to the victims of the Plague would have remained trapped into the teeth and so its genetic material would have been unaffected by external factors. We tried to PCR amplify microbial DNA sequences related to possible diseases proposed according to the descriptions of Thucydides. Six initial attempts for bubonic plague, typhus, anthrax, tuberculosis, cowpox disease and cat-scratch disease failed to detect the respective DNA sequences. At the seventh attempt genetic material of the pathogen causing typhoid fever was identified in studied Athenians of the era of the Plague. We amplified parts of three genes of the bacterium Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi. We followed very strict laboratory conditions in order to exclude the possibility of contamination from the environment, which is always the biggest risk for ancient DNA studies. Furthermore, we isolated total DNA from the soil covering the teeth and performed the same molecular tests with negative results. Consequently, Salmonella enterica Typhi was absent from the surroundings. Anyway, it is known that the bacterium cannot survive in the environment more than a month. Finally, to avoid contamination, we conducted the whole research in three different laboratories in which this pathogen had never entered before. Obviously, we have not completely dismissed the possibility of another coexisting infectious disease yet, but we are certain that at least some victims of the Plague had typhoid fever”.
    The Greek scientists were able for the first time to provide scientific evidence regarding the epidemic and this was a historic triumph of Molecular Biology and Genetics. It is worth mentioning that this research involving ancient DNA from archeological material was the first of its kind in Greece.
    After a careful study of the relevant bibliography, Professor Yapijakis chose for his research a methodology of “suicide” PCR developed by a team from the University of Marseille. The French team had studied teeth from victims of the medieval epidemic of “black death” and they had successfully identified the responsible pathogen of the bubonic plague.
    Although there have been previously some suggestions for transferring the skeletal material and performing this ancient DNA research abroad, the Greek researchers had the strong desire to carry out this investigation in Greece. “It is obvious that our research is a triumph of the rapid development of Molecular Biology techniques which made possible the study of ancient DNA samples. Thirty years ago, we could not even imagine to examine the genetic material of an organism that lived two or three millennia ago”, adds Professor Christos Yapijakis.
    The Greek scientist said that these results should in time be confirmed by the study of other teeth from mass graves of the same period.

    Source:
    DNA Examination of Ancient Dental Pulp Incriminates Typhoid Fever as a Probable Cause of the Plague of Athens. Papagrigorakis M.J., Yapijakis C., Synodinos P.N., Baziotopoulou-Valavani E. International Journal of Infectious Diseases 2006, 10: 206-214. http://www.ijidonline.com/article/S1201-9712%2805%2900178-5/pdf

    Ancient typhoid epidemic reveals possible ancestral strain of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi. Papagrigorakis MJ, Synodinos PN, Yapijakis C. Infection Genetics and Evolution 2007, 7(1): 126-127.

  • Why Science Journalism is necessary in Greece

    The Science Journalism and Communication, the Rebranding Greece campaign , the Policy and the development have something in common: Science.
    Unfortunately, the average of the Greeks aren’t informed enough about science and most of them don’t know exactly what science means.
    The funded research and the produced knowledge are in a very low level. This of course is one of the main reasons for the “brain drain” in Greece. There is no doubt that there are great Greek scientists and researchers that make great careers and produce scientific knowledge outside the country.
    On the other hand there is no science communication. In this country no one talks about science at schools and at universities and the media have underestimate the significant role that they could and should play by communicating science.
    Science communications includes science exhibitions, journalism, Policy and media production. And at this point two problems arise:The first one concerns the big gap between science and journalism. The researchers and the scientists still don’t trust journalists and they prefer to communicate the results of their research by themselves. Sometimes or most of the times in a wrong way. That happens because they don’t know the right way to give science back to citizens and because there is lack of organized press offices at the universities or research centers to take up this competence.
    The second problem refers to the fact that science journalism doesn’t exist in Greece. Everybody knows and writes about everything and this is a real problem. Although, some of the journalists happen to have a scientific background, the majority of them haven’t and they continue to write about science based to their experience.
    The problem grows with the fact that in Greece there is only one official union of journalists, ESIEA and there isn’t a specific one for Science journalists. But the most worryingly is that there isn’t a specific course for Science Journalism and Communication even at the Department of Mass Media Communication at the University. In other words, this specific department “produces” journalists without specification, without knowledge of Science communication.
    Having a professional experience for twenty years and by observing all this situation I tried last year to mobilize my colleagues to set a Greek Association of Science Journalist in order to be more organized and to build a strong bond as a union with EUSJA. The Greek Union ESIEA agreed with this plan and suggested that we should start it immediately. Having the official permission and in accordance with the fundamental rules of the Union, I invited 21 colleagues who understand and write about science in the media having also a scientific background. And this was not very easy. Eventually, after a little research I found them and I discussed with them by the phone (because no one spent some of his precious time to meet me personally) about the lack of scientific communication in Greece.
    They all accepted my ideas and they agreed to set all together the science union.
    But that was the start and the end of this project….
    I should inform you that they all disappeared and I’m still waiting about their reaction, although, I know that all of them are looking (included myself also) for such a scientific union abroad because there isn’t an official one in Greece.
    In my opinion the whole situation has a main political dimension, including political and ethical thinking. It may be hard to tell but I think that the plan is to keep people in the dark in order to manipulate them easier.
    Science communication can aim to generate support for scientific research or study, to inform the public and the decision making, which can be regarded as the cognitive process resulting in the selection of a belief or a course of action among several alternative possibilities.
    Every decision making process produces a final choice that may or may not prompt action and this exactly what the Politicians avoid.
    That’s why I think that Science Communication is absolutely necessary in Greece.