Author: Viola Egikova

  • Which are the next walls to fall?

    By Luca Tancredi Barone,
    ACCC freelance journalist (Spain, Catalan)

    Berlin3

    This November 14 members of EUSJA were offered a grant to attend the Falling Walls Conference in Berlin – the international conference on future breakthroughs in science and society. EUSJA has been invited to this fascinated event not once, and the journalists always could get enough possibilities for interesting articles and useful contacts. Our Spanish colleague, ACCC freelance journalist Luca Tancredi Barone shares his impressions – both positive and negative. Photos: Raili Leino (science journalist from Finland) and from www.falling-walls.com.
     

    It was my first time at a Falling Walls Conference. After being rejected in the first round, when a colleague had to cancel at the last minute, I was able to receive a grant that covered the conference fee and one hotel night.

    The Conference has been truly inspiring for me. A lot of nicely presented speeches on cutting-edge topics, mostly on science, but also on economy, human rights, policies, start-ups. The invited speakers had been carefully selected, and their time slots were respected in an original and entertaining way: a professional mime would intervene to “convince” the speaker to cut it short when time had arrived to leave the stage. The general feeling was that this conference gathered many interesting people, both on the stage and among the public.

    I had a chance to talk with some of the speakers and met people in the public who shared their different background with me. Many journalists also attended the meeting, and it was interesting to meet them too. I am going to prepare some interviews I will also share with you as soon as they are ready. Tweeting during the conference was also entertaining, though I would have expected more interactions. The opening event, on Friday night, was at the Science museum – a very suggestive venue, especially at night – to hold a celebration. And the dinner was in another fascinating museum: the Communication museum. Very nicely chosen environments.

    Despite my general positive feeling about this event, which I plan to attend again in the future, there is still room for improvement in my opinion. First and foremost, the venue is not ideal for the number of people, many of which had to sit on the floor during the conferences. It was also difficult to listen to the forums, small discussions organised during the breaks, where three sets of the scientists talking in the previous sessions where moderated each by a journalist – all the same time in the same, concentrated area. This during the coffee breaks, so while people were trying to get to their coffee, all in the same space. This worsened during lunch time, with very long cues and not very abundant food I have to say. Certainly, not the most important aspect of the otherwise exciting day, but still, given the fact that the venue was in an isolated area, the risk of remaining without anything to eat was high if you were not fast enough.

    Most annoying was the fact that journalistically it was very difficult to perform the interviews. If you needed a quiet place to record your interview, it was impossible. Of the 8 interviews I planned, I was given access to only 4 people, one I had to figure out myself, and I was only given one short slot in a (relatively) quiet room. The rest had to be done in the press room, together with many other people in a very noisy environment. I believe something better could be organized for sure. Finally, despite the fact I had been invited to both the welcoming event and the dinner, I had been cancelled from both lists and had to ask to be admitted in. And, together with a good number of people, had no table to sit for the dinner, and had to dine standing – in the end, it wasn’t a bad experience: I shared the time with interesting people. And the president of Falling Walls came personally to say he was sorry and explain that the no-show percentage at the dinner was unusually low. Easy to forgive but still telling of a may be not too smooth organization.

    Last observation for EUSJA: I think that to better help freelancers, a contribution should have been given to cover flight expenses and at least one extra night – the events were during two days – even in a cheaper place.

    Robert KirshnerJules Hoffmann

    Anne GloverFALLING WALLS 2011 - Radialsystem Berlin

     

     

     

     

  • Are we for sale?

    money1The conference came to an end with a great scandal. No other scheduled speech could be of an interest after the statement of a deputy minister for communication. He was invited to speak to the conference “Journalism in 2012” organized by the faculty of journalism of Moscow University. One could expect some boring address like the officials usually do, but the words of deputy minister broke an academician atmosphere in a lecture hall. “Do you really trust that the journalism has a mission? Then you are giving a wrong motivation to your students. Journalism has no mission, but busyness. Better if you will explain your students from the very beginning: they will do what their boss will say!”

    I have never heard  to conference such emotional and angry protests that followed after the statement. The next day it was news number one discussed in Russian media and different social nets. Of course, journalists felt insulted. Teachers of journalism were shocked. But there were also voices to support scandalous opinion. “Journalism is for sale indeed”, – these persons were saying, – “See, the newspapers will publish any stupid article if it will attract the readers and bring money, the TV channels will produce any false story to be attractive for advertisers and to take the lead over the competitors. Do you find pseudoscience articles every day or pseudoscience movies on TV? Since the audience pays for it, the newspapers or TV channels will produce it. Is not it for sale? Then is journalism busyness or no?”

    These arguments reminded me a discussion during the conference in science journalism we had last October to the North of Russia, some German science journalists participated also being invited by German-Russian Forum. There were a lot of interesting talks, but really hard discussion started when somebody mentioned that nowadays science journalism is nothing but science PR as science journalist works to sale the scientific idea. The audience immediately divided into two opposite groups. One (bigger) insisted that science journalism has its noble goals which are knowledge, progress and so on, the second (smaller) part was saying: it is a relic to speak of a mission of journalism. Media is for sale, thus it will be honest to admit that a journalist works for sale. If so, there is no difference among science journalism and science PR; those who deny it do not get the things evident. This group appealed to us: “Open your eyes! Everything is for sale. Journalism as well” There were Russian as well German journalists from the both sides of our hard discussion.

    Are we really blind relics – those who never agree that journalism is busyness or science journalism and science PR are equal?

  • Black and White – About the reputation of journalism – by Viola Egikova

    “He is a journalist, but he is a honest fellow!” Have you ever heard anything similar? No? Then I have to tell you an unpleasant thing: people do not like journalists. Just think what they say about our profession. Maybe the most innocent proverb on the topic of journalism is: “Lie. But so skillful that I believe it”. Why do we have such an odious reputation?

    “No surprise, answered a scientist whom I asked. There are just a few journalists who will not distort what you say. You speak with him and explain your research, but he will write nonsense for sure, because he may sell it better: the public is pleased to read tales. Why should I like a person whose profession is to be a liar?”

    This is an old antagonism among scientists and journalists. Maybe you heard another proverb: “If you speak with a journalist, you get a falsehood, but if you do not speak with a journalist, you lose your money”. Sure, we look as rather sordid persons in such a conception. But this is what scientists think of our profession doing an exception just for single journalists. Of course, this bad reputation is usually unjust, but it is based on precedents. And the precedents are sad, very sad. We have got one more fact.

    The most popular Russian website www.antropogenez.ru dedicated to human evolution posted an open letter of a well known scientist Dr. Maria Mednikova from the Institute of Archeology which is part of the Russian Academy of Sciences. She wrote about a documentary film from the Russian TV Channel “Culture” – “A City of Giants” which was broadcasted on May 4. That film tells about four-meter-bones, which, as they say, were found in the hills of Armenia. The authors argue that these bones belonged to human beings – ancient giants who used to live in that place.

    To prove the thesis the authors of that documentary interviewed the scientist. Dr. Maria Mednikova wrote in her open letter that the journalists manipulated the interview, cut it and changed the meaning of what she had said. According to her words, she insisted that no four-meter-giants could ever exist, it was against a scientific knowledge. But her words in that documentary were used as if she had proved the hypothesis.

    Since it was not the first time that scientists complained about their words being twisted, we again discussed this topic in our community. One may hear different opinions. Somebody says: a scientist must take the journalist to court. But in my country it is a long, boring and very expensive business without a clear result. Journalists say: let us create a black list of those who are twisting the facts. But this is not realistic: there are plenty of journalists who lie permanently, but feel perfectly.

    Scientists say: no interview any more. This also is not realistic; scientists need communication. Maybe better to show the text before publishing? I remember my discussion with a brilliant German science journalist who told me: he will never agree to show a text before publication. It is against the principles of journalism, he said. And let’s be honest with each other: journalists have to reduce and simplify to make science palatable for a large lay audience. Not every scientist would go along with this.

    Does this all mean that we are always between two fires – good principles or bad reputation? Can we stay white if somebody makes our profession dirty? Black and/or white, I have no answer to that question – who tries a response?

    The drawing is by Kaianders Sempler

  • EUSJA study tour to Saarbrücken

    EUSJA study tour to Saarbrücken

    Schloss DagstuhlUnder the headline “How Computer Science and Materials Science are improving the world”, EUSJA journalists are invited to a press trip to the Saarland University from March 28-30, 2012:

    Which technologies can ensure privacy in the so-called World Wide Web? How can you enhance websites with three-dimensional content? How can you use three-dimensional computer graphics for other disciplines like Materials Science?

    These questions will be addressed by the press tour to Saarland University from March 28 to 30, 2012. We would like to invite you to take part at the program, which introduces Saarland University in Saarbrücken and Schloss Dagstuhl, the Leibniz Center for Informatics in Wadern.

    Computer science at Saarland University has played a cutting-edge role from its beginning. It has developed to become an internationally acclaimed location for this discipline. Top-tier research institutes with an international reputation contribute to this prestige. Besides the Department of Computer Science, these include the Max Planck Institute for Informatics, the Max Planck Institute for Software Systems, the German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence (DFKI), and the Cluster of Excellence on “Multimodal Computing and Interaction”.

    The department of Materials Science and Engineering of Saarland University develops similarly. It maintains close connections to the Material Engineering Center Saarland, a Steinbeis Research Center, the Fraunhofer Institute for Non-Destructive Testing, the Leibniz Institute for New Materials, which are also located on the campus. There are only a few universities in Germany that can provide such a major focus to this research area.

    Located in the picturesque baroque manor Schloss Dagstuhl, 50 kilometres from Saarbrücken, the Leibniz Center for Informatics brings together prominent computer scientists, young researchers, and practitioners from all over the world. In this way, it promotes fundamental and applied research, continuing education and technology transfer in informatics.

    Programme for the Saarland study tour. We are looking forward to welcoming 15 journalists in Saarbrücken from March 28 to 30.  If fewer than eight journalists register, we will have to postpone the tour. Therefore, please register as soon as possible.

  • Scanbalt Study Trip to Szczecin

    Scanbalt Study Trip to Szczecin

    In 2011, ScanBalt celebrates it’s 10th anniversary. With the headline »10 Years ScanBalt BioRegion – Towards a Balanced Regional Development and Smart Specialization in the Baltic Sea Region«, ScanBalt invites EUSJA-journalists to participate in a study trip, that will take them to Sczecin, Greifswald and Heringsdorf.

    The purpose of the trip is to learn about the activities, meet the actors and to experience crossborder cooperation projects in life sciences in the ScanBalt BioRegion/Northern Europe. This time focusing on Northern Germany and Northern Poland at the university cities Greifswald, Germany, and Szczecin, Poland.

    Read more about the trip in the attached PDF-document.

    Key words: technology transfer, molecular medicine, industrial Biotechnology, biomaterial, crossborder cooperation,  telemedicine.
    Participants: By invitation of ca. 15 international scientific journalists.
    Time: Tuesday, 20.Sept. – Friday, 23. Sept. 2011
    Deadline for application: August 25.
    Please apply via your national representative.