Tag: European Commission

  • Make scientific facts great again. What Europe can do about it!

    Make scientific facts great again. What Europe can do about it!

    In recent years the world has seen a surge of populist movements that deny or distort scientific facts. Europe is not immune to these developments as can be seen in electoral results from all corners of the continent, West and East, North and South. The session will discuss the reasons for these developments and discuss strategies to put scientific evidence back into its rightful place in political and societal debates in Europe. A session submitted to the European Conference of Science Journalists 2017 Copenhagen by the European Commission, facilitated by Johannes Klumpers, Directorate General Research & Innovation, moderated by Wolfgang Chr. Goede, International Science Journalist, German Science Writers TELI, World Federation of Science Journalists WFSJ.

    BE AWARE OF THE DARK MIDDLE AGES
    Wolfgang Chr. Goede

    The common ground for this session and panel is the International Science March last April. As the moderator outlined in his introduction, “many of us have participated in this in our respective countries”. This is a historic and political landmark. For the first time in history scientists throughout the world took to the streets to demand scientific truth and evidence.

    The political background: Post-truth and alternative facts, plainly speaking lies attributed to last year’s US presidential campaign, the victor Donald Trump and the current US administration. The has culminated most recently in the pull-out of the US from the Paris climate agreement, denying all scientific evidence that carbondioxide contribute to global warming and needs to be cut down.

    Parallel to this development in the US is the populist rise in Europe, Hungary, Netherlands, Germany, France and UK: Brexit occurred on not substantiated information, rather emotions than facts and evidence.

    Overall, western democracies are at risk to fall back into the pre-enlightenment era, not to say into dark middle ages.

    The statements of four distinguished panelists follow.

    DEFENDING SCIENTIFIC FACTS IN EUROPEAN POLITICS: A REPORT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD
    Angelika Mlinar, Member of the European Parliament , Austria, Liberal Party

    Today media play an important role in the political environment and it is not always easy to make politics appealing for headlines by pointing out facts and evidence. It became especially difficult in recent years, where some political forces and part of the media became less reluctant to use wrong or partly-wrong information -making a politician’s effort to use accurate research results and facts even more crucial.

    However, with social media news are spreading much faster than ever before. When fake news articles or any piece of information is posted on Facebook, Twitter, etc. it is basically impossible to revoke it. It can get shared, included in other postings and repeated by anyone, including politicians. Fake news, spread on purpose, do usually not include (too) many scientific facts, but target the emotions of the individual. This is what makes it hard to counter their arguments. People seem not really open to purely scientific and logical arguments. Combing facts with emotions might therefore be one possible strategy to promote a positive image for fact-based policy-making.

    There are several ways to promote and defend scientific facts in the political environment. It is never easy to change a person’s opinion on a matter though. Especially if it is grounded on an emotional reasoning. However, it is essential for us politicians and policy-makers to base our decisions on proven facts rather than the piece of information that is most comfortable for our work. That is why we will continue our work to promote and propose scientific evidence as the foundation for our policy proposals.

    Examples to elaborate on include:

    • The recently resurfacing discussion on parents refusing to get their children vaccinated – Italy being one of the latest examples of a strict intervention based on scientific results by introducing mandatory vaccination for children.
    • Glyphosate and the way the European Commission handles/d the extension of the approval.
    • Climate Change or any other “fake news” story with Donald Trump at the center of attention.

    MAKING SURE THAT FACTS ARE NOT SCREWED UP IN BRUSSELS
    Sofie Vanthournout, Director Sense about Science EU (Belgium)

    Audience in Copenhagen’s Concert Hall (c) EC DG Research & Innovation

    There is a growing concern about a ‘post truth society’ and a belief among some commentators that the public is unwilling to engage with the evidence about complex policy issues. This risks MEPs and the media treating EU citizens as if they don’t care about the truth or accountability.

    But Sense about Science experiences every day that people do care deeply about facts and evidence in public life. On 21 June, we’ve brought over 100 people to the European Parliament, where 15 citizens each spoke for 1 minute on why evidence matters to them. They said:

    • We expect the Commission to use evidence when making policy.
    • We expect commissioners to explain their reasoning.
    • We expect Parliament to seek and to scrutinise reasoning behind policies.

    Frans Timmermans, first vice president of the European commission and parliamentarians from different political groups have responded to these demands.

    To make sure that MEPs live up to the citizen’s expectations and go on to seek, scrutinise or use evidence in policymaking, we will help citizens to ask for evidence in EU policy, through our Ask for Evidence campaign and we will organise a citizen-led review to monitor the ‘best and worst’ of MEPs responses over the next 12 months.

    AND THEN THEY CAME FOR THE EXPERTS – LESSONS FROM BREXIT
    Dame Anne Glover, Former Chief Scientific Adviser to the President of the European Commission, now Vice-Principal for External Affairs and Dean for Europe, University of Aberdeen.

    On the 23rd June 2016 the UK voted in a referendum of EU membership and decided by a narrow majority to leave the EU.  Only 72% of those eligible voted.

    The campaign leading up to the vote was remarkable in being almost completely evidence-free.  The Remain campaign failed to make a positive evidence-informed case for staying in the EU and the Leave campaign, supported by the tabloid press, flooded the media with misinformation about the EU and used false information to fan citizens fears about free movement of EU citizens in particular.

    Even now, over 1 year later, there is still a state of denial regarding the impact Brexit will have on the UK and even more worrying, the Government have not published any evidence regarding likely scenarios that might result.  This is an unprecedented example of how bad things can get if we turn our back on evidence-led decision-making.

    MAKING SCIENTIFIC FACTS GREAT AGAIN: HOW – THE COMMISSION’S SCIENTIFIC ADVICE MECHANISM SAM

    Rolf Heuer, former Director-General of CERN, Chair of the European Commission’s High Level Group of Scientific Advisors (SAM)

    The High Level Group of scientific advisors of the European Commission’s Scientific Advice Mechanism (SAM HLG) is unique. It speaks directly with the College of European Commissioners, and works with a consortium of European scientific academies which provide expertise rapidly, and on the widest possible range of scientific domains. It is supported by a well-resourced team in the EC’s Directorate General for Research and Innovation.

    Transparency is fundamental to the SAM HLG: members are independent of the Commission and appointed in a personal capacity, and the HLG only examines evidence which is in the public domain when producing its advice. Moreover, the SAM HLG is honest about uncertainty and takes care to communicate this to the users of its advice: this is particularly important when evidence is incomplete and when society holds strong views about the issues at stake.

    The HLG provides advice to the College having been asked to do so, but can also propose advice to the College. To date, it has delivered on request, scientific opinions for climate and cybersecurity policies as well as ‘explanatory notes’ on ‘new techniques in agricultural biotechnology’ and on issues surrounding the regulatory approval of ‘glyphosate’ as an ingredient in plant protection products. Each of these pieces of advice is being considered in the review or development of policies in corresponding areas. The HLG is presently working on scientific opinions on the sustainable use of marine resources and on the regulation of plant protection products. Shortly, the HLG will propose to provide advice to the College of European Commissioners on a number of other topics.

    (c) EC DG Research & Innovation

    All of the activities of the Scientific Advice Mechanism including the minutes of workshops and meetings, as well as all of the products of the HLG, including scientific opinions and explanatory notes are available on the SAM website.

    As to the discussion and results of this topic, the following highlights deserve bullet points:

    • Commitment and Courage: We all, but especially also science journalists have to try to do a better job in our daily communication and not be afraid to pick up on controversial subjects.
    • Recognition of the constraints of science: As every other profession, scientists are also driven by their values (Anne Glover)
    • More accountability: Scientists have to become better at explaining to taxpayers how they spend their money and what the research is good for (Anne Glover)
    • Science is no fake: Look at your smart phone and appreciate all the physics it contains (Rolf Heuer)
    • All in all, there is no pointing fingers at each other, we’re all responsible for our democracy and well-being.

    SESSION VIDEO
    https://twitter.com/hashtag/SAMGroupEU?src=hash

    All pictures (c) EC DG Research & Innovation

  • Atomium Culture’s official response to Jens Degett

    Atomium Culture’s official response to Jens Degett

    We received this reply to the recent post on Atomium Culture
    by the President of the Danish Association of Science Journalists Jens Degett
    “Atomium Culture and The Role of the Media in Responsible Research and Innovation”

    Brussels – 3 April 2013

    OBJECT: Response to post by Jens Degett published on 24 March 2013

    Dear Jens Degett,

    The inquisitive and questioning nature of journalists is precisely one of the key qualities of the current press that need to persevere in order to ensure the development of Responsible Research and Innovation as the EISRI Summit in Dublin clearly pointed out.

    However, on behalf of Atomium Culture I would like to correct some of the facts that you report in your blog that are in effect incorrect or not precise (in order of appearance):

    1) The EISRI Summits are NOT events organised by the European Commission (nor was the Danish Science in Dialogue conference an EISRI Summit). EISRI stands for “European Intersectoral Summit on Research and Innovation” and is an event that Atomium Culture organises every 18 months to bring together leading representatives from academia, media, industry and policy makers to discuss a key issue relating to the relationship between science and society. For the Irish Presidency of the Council of the EU, the Department for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation decided to use this platform, working in particular with the institutions engaged in Atomium Culture in Ireland (Trinity College Dublin and the Irish Times) to develop the theme of “The Role of the Media in Responsible Research and Innovation”.

    2) Atomium Culture is NOT a media organisation. Atomium Culture is a Brussels-based international non-profit organisation that brings together in its platform leading universities (http://atomiumculture.eu/node/33), media (http://atomiumculture.eu/node/92) and industry (http://atomiumculture.eu/node/43) to promote knowledge sharing and “out of the box” thinking on issues regarding the development of a European knowledge society; AC was launched publicly at the European Parliament by the leaders of the institutions engaged and by V. Giscard d’Estaing, currently Honorary President. The Board is chaired by Felipe Gonzalez and consists of the representatives of all sectors engaged (http://atomiumculture.eu/node/63).

    3) The possible construction of an EU Science Media Centre is a possible project that Atomium Culture is assessing whether or not to promote. It was suggested as a positive project by the representatives of the organisations engaged in AC following the Expert Panel Discussion organised together with Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung in March 2012. At this meeting in Frankfurt, several external organisations were also present, representing different fields of science communication. Since then, AC has organised numerous meetings with the different stakeholders to assess how such an institution could benefit science communication in Europe. EUSJA has been invited and represented during some of these meetings.

    4) Our Executive Director Erika Widegren was present at the Odense meeting upon invitation of the European Commission and Danish Ministry. Further, Ms Widegren was present at the ESOF Panel on Responsible Research and Innovation together with Mr Waldemar Kütt, Deputy Head of Cabinet of Commissioner Geoghegan-Quinn and Mr Uffe Toudal Pedersen, Permanent Secretary of the Danish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Higher Education.

    5) The conference topics, speaker list and material was prepared by the Conference Coordination Committee and the European Commission. The Conference Coordination Committee included representatives from Atomium Culture, the Irish Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, Trinity College Dublin and The Irish Times.

    6) Speakers at the conference included leaders and key representatives from academia, media, industry and policy makers (including the President of EUSJA Barbara Drillsma and President Emeritus Istvan Palugyai). The selection of speakers was done upon suggestion of all partners engaged in the conference and represented all different stakeholders and brought to the table the different perspectives of the debate. Full list of speakers can be found on http://eisri-summit.eu/programme-2/

    7) The aims of the Summit are clearly defined as:
    – Continue the conversation initiated during the “Science in Dialogue”, a Conference held during the Danish presidency to develop a European model for Responsible Research and Innovation;
    – Explore the role of media in the European model for Responsible Research and Innovation;
    – Facilitate the formation of professional networks, knowledge sharing, and exchange of best practices;
    – Come up with concrete recommendations on what has to be done in the short term at a European level to reach the long term objectives of smart, inclusive and sustainable growth.

    In addition to the above corrections, Atomium Culture would further like to clarify that it is not a media organisation involved directly in science communication. What Atomium Culture does is bring together academia, media and industry to assess some of the underlying issues and support the development of innovative projects that can benefit the organisations engaged in the platform.

    AC is a strong proponent of the fact that “Europe already has excellent research universities, media organisations and industry”. AC works with the newspapers engaged in the platform, in particular with our Editorial Committee (composed of the chief science editors of Der Standard, El País, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, The Irish Times and Il Sole 24 Ore) to find new ways of collaboration to benefit all partners and in particular the relationship between science and society.

    From the reaction of members of EUSJA during several of the meetings organised by Atomium Culture in 2012–2013 we understand that there is a clear concern by some of the members of EUSJA relating to some of the new projects that Atomium Culture is promoting—in particular, the development of an EU Science Media Centre.

    We believe that these fears are unfounded and would welcome, as stated several times to members of EUSJA, to have an open and constructive discussion on these themes and to see how EUSJA could play a role in the development of this institution. The EU SMC would be developed to support journalists across Europe so the input of EUSJA is certainly very welcome. Fabio Turone has already voiced some of the concerns and Atomium Culture is doing its utmost to develop a project that reflects the different needs and concerns of ALL stakeholders. There is strong support for the development of an EU Science Media Centre by academic institutions, established media, industry, NGOs and policy makers, each of which sees the usefulness of such an institution.

    Again, thank you for your comments and we hope that EUSJA and its members will welcome the suggestion for a concrete and direct discussion on these themes in the future.

    Renato Tagliaferro
    Director of External Relations
    Atomium Culture