Tag: investigation

  • Investigative Data Harvest -– The rise of the new Woodwards & Bernsteins

    Investigative Data Harvest -– The rise of the new Woodwards & Bernsteins

    (c) Wikimedia Commons
    (c) Wikimedia Commons

    These days is the worldwide roll-out of the movie how Hollywood views WikiLeaks” and the figure behind it Julian Assange. The title “The Fifth Estate”was in Germany translated into “Fifth Power” and reminds of the fact that traditionally the power system is divided and balanced between the Executive Branch, Legislature and Judiciary with a fourth level on top, a controlling system which is journalism and the media.

    While the  internet has opened new avenues of communication, participation and transparency it has severely devaluated journalism. On blogs and social platforms every user is a communicator and many times also a journalist. Established media is struggling with this new competition with impacts on the economic performance and overall quality loss.

    However there is a newly emerging group of internet-apt journalists who say: “The internet is our exit strategy out of times of crisis.” It offers a unique chance for investigative research, gather information on complex and highly sensitive issues, provide suitable graphics and publish them. There is at this point nothing illegal about it or breaking the law. It’s just a matter of passion and education. Thus, the media could reconquer its vaning position of the fourth power in the society and start to thrive again.

    The eighth World Conference of Science Journalists in Helsinki WCSJ 2013 Helsinki addressed this newly unfolding technique of journalists. Dino Trescher, member of the German Science Writers TELI, helped to organize the session “Data Explored – The Code That Underpins the Future of Science Journalism” -> http://wcsj2013.org/data-explored-code-underpins-future-journalism/ and reports here about the outcome and findings, in a short overview and a more in-depth view with a toolbox and cases such as grand-style tobacco smuggling, the OffshoreLeaks Tax Fraud, and environmental Investigation. The steps he and the co-chairmen of this session recommend are:

    Mining, Filtering, Visualisation, Story.

    Trescher & colleagues claim that “unique stories are often hidden in mountains of data, documents and statistics and are distributed all over the internet”. This allows to discover unknown facts which interrelate and reveal new contexts. Journalists who are capable of penetrating the net and interpreting the facts come up with new layers of truth. Thus they render a valuable service to democracy which can make up for the lost capacity as gatekeeper and information broker. An example presented by the authors:

    Keith Ng, a freelance journalist from Wellington, New Zealand, extracted data from a self-service counter in a social security office and thereby accessed an enormous amount of government data. The files from New Zealand’s Ministry of Social Development included names and addresses of chil-dren living in protected care, investigators and clients in fraud investigations, invoices, and medical prescriptions — the beginning of what became the government’s largest ever security breach. But Keith did not sell the story to the media, he blogged about it. So instead of being paid for a few lines, he put a link at the bottom of the story that led to a donation page on GiveALittle.co.nz. A decision which made him earn a lot of money.

    “Success in this new field depends on the data driven narration”, the authors point out. This requires the adequate use of new media, the visualisation by more or less interactive graphic charts, innovative narratives and interactive websites

    One of the worldwide leaders in data journalism is the British Guardian. “Comment is free, but facts are sacred”, is Simon Rogers quoted. Some years ago people just wanted to say what they thought. “Now I think it’s, increasingly, people want to find out what the facts are”.

    From stock prices and soccer results to traffic and weather reports, statistics have always been the key in the media. Nowadays however more and more statistics are freely available, through governments, large organisations like the World Bank or the investigative portal Wikileaks. The computer and smart software make it easier to rummage through mountains of data and display the results graphically.

    The aggregation of data, networks between major publications are the future – whether in the form of cooperation between newspapers across borders, whether in the form of multinational search pools or working with foundations and universities, suggest the autors. The data reveals that since 9-11 governments have put more money than ever before into the industrial military complex. Another pillar of the society which needs to be probed is the technological scientific industrial complex.

    The harvest of data becomes a joint effort. The Guardian regularly publishes the data sources behind their stories and asks the reader to join in.

    Adrian Holovaty, founder of EveryBlock, offers another example how data search changes and improves journalism. “Say a newspaper has written a story about a local fire. Being able to read that story on a cell phone is fine and dandy”, he says. But what he really wants to be able to do is explore the raw facts of that story, one by one: “With layers of attribution, and an infrastructure for comparing the details of the fire—date, time, place, victims, fire station number, distance from fire department, names and years experience of firemen on the scene, time it took for firemen to arrive—with the details of previous fires. And subsequent fires, whenever they happen.”

    That British and US media seem to be leading the way through the data jungle, is no coincidence: in the USA data is readily available through freedom of information legislation. An additional thrust is provided by the so-called open-data policy in the US and the UK – always evoked by the clearly audi-ble reputation of online and civil rights activists.

    Due to this the LA Times could log the performance of almost the entire teaching staff of Los Angeles: It published the official rating of 6000 primary school teachers in 470 public elementary schools in the city. The basis of assessment is the performance of students in standardised final exams. Readers of the LA Times can now see any teacher’s record with information on career and “effectiveness”.

    A convincing technique with convincing examples, however the question remains: What can data journalism do for science journalists. This paper is open for discussion!

    Sources

    Datajournalism Handbook:
    http://datajournalismhandbook.org/1.0/en/
    free download – also prepared in Spanish

    Free Online Data Journalism Course
    http://datadrivenjournalism.net/
    http://datadrivenjournalism.net/
    http://datadrivenjournalism.net/

    For Training & Promotion: European Journalism Centre Netherlands
    http://ejc.net/

    Datenjournalist.de (in German):
    http://datenjournalist.de/datenjournalismus-im-oktober-september-2013/

    DATA JOURNALISM READER, SHORT VERSION
    WCSJ_reader_dataexplored_shortversion_trescher (1)

    LONG VERSION
    WCSJ_reader_data explored_longversion_tobacco case, offshoreleaks tax fraud_trescher (1)

  • Midsummer Ethics

    Midsummer Ethics

    WCSJ 2013 Helsinki 074

    During midsummer, the Finnish capital was the northernmost extension of the Mediteranean Sea – with special light effects. Blue sunny skies and temperatures of up to 35 centigrades made the University of Helsinki a sauna and made the participants of the 8th World Conference of Science Journalists work up a sweat. How refreshing to take a stroll at night to the pleasant waters of the harbor, relax in one of the open air cafés and bars, and try some magic mushroom gummies! Just like in Rome or Barcelona, confusing, however, that at midnight it felt like 9 in the evening. During Helsinki’s famous “White Nights” its skies stay in twilight. All this contributed to a very special conference ambience.

    Vesa Niinikangas, the outgoing president of the World Federation of Science Journalists and former EUSJA treasurer, perfectly lived up to this. In his red jacket and with his straw hat he was a charming host. He harvested the fruits of seven years of hard work. Vesa and his team could welcome 807 delegates from 77 countries. They engaged in well over 50 sessions, workshops and panels, which in the majority revolved around the question how to become better in the job and draw the line between science journalism and science communication.

    The special emphasis of WCSJ 2013 Helsinki was, more than during previous world conferences, put on ethics and democracy, such as “freedom of expression” and “critical questioning in the public sphere”.

    WCSJ 2013 Helsinki Istvan lowres

    As EUSJA president Barbie Drillsma pointed out in a letter to all members, the umbrella of Europe’s science journalists managed to engage in four sessions, in which not only the board but a sizeable number of members got involved. Three scholarships to young professionals from the Netherlands, Ireland and Spain were awarded. Besides, EUSJA’s treasurer Priit Ennet organized a study trip with twenty plus participants to Estonia, or better e-Estonia, the first country in the world which is establishing a completely internet-based society   >>> https://www.eusja.org/e-e-e-stonia-the-new-baltic-tiger/

    Altogether this world conference was very successful also for Europe, thanks to a close and generous cooperation with the Finnish organizers. EUSJA is very grateful for this. With its contributions, EUSJA tried to address the goal of the conference and to advance ethics, a critical attitude and democracy.

    The capacity building session “Blood Infusion for Staggering Science Journalism” dealt with exactly this. Associate board member Fabio Turone laid out the principles of investigative science journalism. A lot of science is not as truthful and objective as it is supposed to be. Listening very carefully to what sources say, how they say it and whether they use words like “sensitive” is the job of an investigative science reporter.

    He must dig much deeper into the material and data than his colleagues, sniff out contradictions, cultivate relationships to the research community, record carefully all his findings, never rely on a single source but always get a second opinion, keep his editor informed about progress, be patient and prepare for months of investigation, get the story watertight and ask before publication the incriminated persons for their version, generally be ready for conflict, if push comes to shove even anticipate legal action.

    Turone, a specialist in medicine, knew what he was talking about and was once sued for a story. Besides, he referred to the guidelines of K.S. Jayaraman, a very successful investigative reporter in India >>> http://www.scidev.net/global/communication/practical-guide/how-to-be-an-investigative-science-journalist-1.html

    WCSJ 2013 GA lowres

    Another source of misinformation are false or misleading statistics, many times arbitrarily used. Hans van Maanen exposed them in his exercise “Smelling the rat between the numbers”. He recommended, like Turone, tough questioning. A researcher should be asked “where is the publication” and “show me the numbers”.  This helps the science journalist to figure out the plausibility and the human dimension. “1 in 1000 is a lot”, said van Maanen, “but how lot?”

    Don’t accept a percentage, he instructed his audience, “but always go for absolute numbers”. A 10 percent increase might sound a lot, he added, but if it’s only 3 people, forget it, “that’s just noise”. For people who really want to dig into numbers the lecturer offes an online course on statistics >>> http://www.wfsj.org/course/lesson.htm?e=e09#L09P00

    Not only numbers, but also badly told stories are a deterrent to readers and media users. To make an article meaningful and attractive, said Angela Posada-Swafford, the writers must apply the rules of storytelling. For example

    • unique first sentences (“Mary was a dark-haired beauty with a hole in her heart”), usage of comparisons (“a meteorite is like the ice-cream they serve at Chinese restaurants: frozen inside, with a crispy coat outside”), 
    • use the writing as a movie director would use the camera with long shots and close ups,
    • SHOW and don’t tell, 
    • change perspective and tell the story through the view of a patient, an animal, a molecule, 
    • continuous action, 
    • sounds (“rain clatters on the roof”); 
    • verbs are everything, 
    • a paragraph is a unit of thought (the more elegant the thought, the shorter the paragraph), 
    • at the end revise, revise, revise and read out loud the story and ask yourself “Does it sing well?”.

    Posada-Swafford finished with an exercise and asked to write the opening sentence of a story and to incorporate these three words “tangled, hair, fresh” in 25 words within five minutes. Many experienced writers failed, but not the teacher: “She was gasping, in need of fresh air, suffering from the penetrating pain she had caused to herself while combing her tangled hair, still wondering what could have possibly gone wrong with the experiment”.  >>> http://www.angelaposadaswafford.com/nueva/esp/intro.html

    WCSJ 2013 EUSJA Stand lowres

    Curricula & Summaries, Pictures & Videos, Mission Statement of this EUSJA Training >>> https://www.eusja.org/eusjas-workshop-at-the-2013-helsinki-world-conference-of-science-journalists-on-blood-infusion/

    Very much in line with the conference goals to foster more professionalism and societal dialogue was the session “Science Debates as a Tool and Opportunity for Science Journalists”. It was organized by former EUSJA president Hajo Neubert and was originally presented already at ESOF 2010 Torino. It provides new platforms for science journalists as the moderators of the discussion between science, society and politics.

    Debates about scientific issues and policy also enlarge the frames of reporting and make journalists aware of the fact that science and technology are always embedded in the entire society and have a political context. That was stated by Shawn Otto, inventor of the US Science Debate 2008 and 2012, in his input about the “Science Democracy Gap” >>>
    https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B90P5CW89-mAdER6bDVFdlo1dHc/edit?usp=sharing.

    As the history of climate change shows, “democracy is co-opted by private interests” and manipulations, Otto said. “We need to report on the political interests of science”, he demanded and finished with the sentence: “Science debate are needed to save democracy.”

    WCSJ 2013 Helsinki Priit lowres

    Priit Ennet, the EUSJA treasurer, had run a science debate in Estonia  proposed an international science debate with the following criteria:

    • continuous, 
    • decentralized, 
    • transparent,
    • inclusive, 
    • non-hierarchal, 
    • diverse and 
    • voluntary

    Klaartje Jaspers, EUSJA conference scholar from the Netherlands, wants to organize a science debate for “science unlimited”, a science festival in Den Haag in 2014 >>> www.scienceunlimited.nl.

    Oppressed dialogues addressed Istvan Palugyai, the Hungarian EUSJA delegate and former EUSJA president in the session “Science journalism in totalitarian countries and its impacts to the present time”. In totalitarian times, distortion was everywhere, he reported.

    “Now it’s more subtle, but no less devious” and journalists have to be extra vigilant, he said. For example, almost half of Hungaria’s power is generated by a Russian nuclear power plant, “but cost benefits and safety are never debated”, Palugyai regretted.

    WCSJ 2013 Helsinki Jim lowres

    James Cornell, President of the International Science Writers Association ISWA, supported this view by adding examples of the United States. From the development of the atomic bomb, over biosecurity to global warming, US science is always part of the political agenda and due to manipulation, said Cornell, thus reinforcing the message of his fellow countryman Shawn Otto. Sources may talk a lot but reveal little valuable information, in other words:

    Heavy hand censorship has transformed into “velvet-gloved” manners of US bureaucrats, “the difference is just a matter of style”, concluded Cornell.

    An article of this very well received session was published by Nalaka Gunawardene >>> http://collidecolumn.wordpress.com/2013/06/30/when-worlds-collide-72-open-science-and-closed-societies-can-it-work/.

    Also SciDev.Net reported on this session. It also quoted Jim Cornell.  He was asked what nowadays could be done, when authoritarian governments oppress journalists and prevent access to information, like for example in some Latin American countries. The ISWA President responded:

    “We need to build better networks that help us to put some pressure on the repressive governments.” >>> 

    http://www.scidev.net/global/journalism/scidev-net-at-large/wcsj-2013-day-one.html

    The panel had been organized by EUSJA’s vice president Viola Egikova, a resident of Moscow. She had won for it many delegates of former East Bloc countries such as Blanca Jergovic, Croatia, and Marina Huzvarova, Czech Republic. Alexandru Mironov, Romania, presented his science books written over the decades and said that he actively participated 1989 in the revolution against Ceausescu. But he had not imagined that science journalism would so much deteriorate after the end of the communist regime.

    Not only political journalists, but also science journalists are watchdogs was a central message of the session, which Viola Egikova underlined by pointing out: On the map of the freedom of the press 2013 the Finnish guests belong to the few countries, which enjoy unconditional and unrestricted liberty.

    WCSJ 2013 Helsinki Viola lowres

    Obviously also encouraged by this session, the organizer engaged right after the end of the conference in a protest against an attempt to disempower and destroy the Russian Academy of Science. Egikova wrote on the EUSJA website:

    “It seems the session of totalitarian countries EUSJA had in Helsinki arrived home with me! As if somebody heard what I was saying and decided to give an example how it worked in a country with a totalitarian past.” >>>

    https://www.eusja.org/no-reforms-in-secrecy/
    EUSJA delegates and other joined in >>>
    https://www.eusja.org/russian-academy-of-sciences-threatened-by-new-law/
    https://www.eusja.org/international-support-to-russian-scientists/
    The Danish Delegate Jesper Odde Madsen circulated a petition >>>
    https://www.change.org/en-GB/petitions/russian-government-preserve-freedom-of-science-in-russia-pull-the-bill-back

    Highlight of EUSJA’s World Conference activities was the session about Horizon 2020 and how science journalism ties into this new EU strategy. The panel, chaired by Barbie Drillsam and consisting of Menelaos Sotiriou, associate board member, and Martin Schneider, German WPK delegate, welcomed a highranking official of the European Union, Begoña Arano, Head of Communication, representing Robert-Jan Smits, Director-General for Research & Innovation, European Commission, Brussels.

    She said that the EU will invest between 2014 and 2020 up to 70 billion euros in research and development. The goal of the session was to make sure that science journalism will be included. The decision is still pending, responded the guest, however she made a firm commitment that “science journalism is needed in the society”.

    In his presentation Sotiriou made clear that unlike communicators “we are not disseminators of science”. EUSJA rather could offer workshops, dialogue sessions, trainings and study trips to promote the exchange of knowledge between science and society. Important, he pointed out, is to identify the needs of the taxpayers. Science debates with a targeted audience could help to achieve this as much as “educate researchers about the audience”. >>> EUprojects_Phases_EUSJA

    WCSJ 2013 Helsinki Marina lowres

    Martin Schneider summarized complementary negotiations with Smits during the past months which circled around three fields of interest: Summer schools with training for journalists, a European conference of science journalists parallel to ESOF 2014 Copenhagen, a fund for investigative science journalism. Barbie Drillsma reaffirmed that science journalist are not cheerleaders for science, but provide an enabling contribution to the society as a whole.

    The 8th World Conference of Science Journalists ended with a fierce call for action of Satu Lipponen, president of the conference, “to promote freedom of expression, access, transparency, and better communication among public and private organizations involved in scientific research and policy”. This is crucial to science journalism and its important role in informing the general public about science and its implications for society, she said and added:

    “Science journalists should strive to communicate the perspectives of crucial stakeholders without compromising journalistic independence.”

    WCSJ 2013 Helsinki 100


     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    FURTHER LINKS

    WCSJ 2013 Helsinki Webcasts
    http://wcsj2013.org/webcast/

    Helsinki Statement
    http://wcsj2013.org/wcsj2013-statement/

    Free photos
    http://www.flickr.com/photos/wcsj2013

    Tweet images
    http://storify.com/WCSJ2013

    Facebook material (open)
    https://www.facebook.com/wcsj2013

    Sci.Dev Coverage
    http://www.scidev.net/global/journalism/scidev-net-at-large/wcsj-2013-day-one.html
    http://www.scidev.net/global/journalism/scidev-net-at-large/wcsj-2013-day-two.html
    http://www.scidev.net/global/journalism/scidev-net-at-large/wcsj-2013-day-three.html

    all pictures (c) WC  Goede