Tag: science journalism

  • How to prepare for the next pandemic

    This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is maski1.jpg

    The Science and Politics of Covid-19 (Springer, 2021) is one of the first popular science books published on the ongoing pandemic. Combining scientific rigour and journalistic style, the book retraces the history and the management of the pandemic in several countries. It draws upon lessons learned during the crisis, discusses the emergence of “science politics,” and answers the question: why has science failed?

    This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is cover-1.jpg

    Everything we have seen about the Covid-19 outbreak corroborates with Rudolf Virchow, the 19th century father of pathological anatomy when he said that “an epidemic is a social phenomenon with some medical aspects.” The biggest fear since World War II, the coronavirus pandemic highlighted mistakes in government strategies and scientific research. Based on the latest research and interviews with experts from China, France, the United Kingdom, the United States and other countries, this popular science book provides an insider’s view on this major crisis which tells us a lot about the relations between science and society.

    In Short Covid-19 came out of the blue. On January 2, 2020, WHO issued a global alert on the emergence of several cases of “pneumonia of unknown cause” in Wuhan, China. Except in Beijing, most governments did not show any panic and merely set up a daily monitoring of the incubating epidemic. Donald Trump mocked the “Chinese virus” and claimed that “everything is under control.” This story is about a collective failure. Some of the most scientifically advanced countries have the highest Covid-19 mortality. With probably more than 10 million deaths as of today, the new coronavirus caused a rise of 20% in the annual number of deaths worldwide[1].

    Why has Science failed? Although most governments based their Covid-19 strategy on science, scientists failed to have a decisive influence on decision-makers—except in China—, which created genuine “time bombs.” The accelerated development of vaccines does not erase past months’ errors. More worryingly, experts themselves acknowledge that they did not rise to the challenge. Covid-19 also highlighted the weakness of democratic regimes and the power of technocapitalism. The “politics” of science came frontstage during the crisis, unveiling links between the production of science and the private sector, personal struggles among researchers who strive for recognition and authority, and the intermingling of science with politics.

    What Did We Learn? Here are 10 messages and recommendations developed in the book:

    1. Politicians and scientists have a shared responsibility for the mismanagement of the crisis. Many experts acknowledge that they did not rise to the challenge and underestimated the contagiousness of the virus and the dangerousness of the disease
    2. A major political mistake was that countries pulled down their blinds, locked their doors, and promoted national approaches rather than international cooperation
    3. We are not certain that SARS-CoV-2 originated in China as the coronavirus was already circulating in Europe in early December 2019 (at least in France and Italy)
    4. We did not learn the lessons from previous epidemics. Countries that have performed the best are those that implemented non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) as soon as possible. Speed is everything
    5. Mismanagement, miscommunication and incomprehensible delays led to genuine “time bombs.” Prevention of an epidemic does not start when the epidemic starts
    6. Expert committees should not be created “ex nihilo” but attached to the competent administration departments in order to secure decision processes and communication
    7. The crisis accelerated the development of “science politics” at an unprecedented scale, unveiling the links between the production of science and the private sector, the intermingling of science with politics and the political objectives of some experts
    8. The overall mismanagement also reflects the importance of overspecialisation and miscommunication, which has become a way of life in our society
    9. Despite rapid advances on vaccines, the pandemic will not end before several months or years have passed. Herd immunity may never be reached
    10. The resistance to masks and vaccines show that scientific knowledge disseminates slowly. It is now time for political distancing to put the basics first: develop science, fight ignorance.

    Background Covid-19 is the disease created by a new coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2, which appeared at the end of 2019. The virus’ genome is contained in a single strand of RNA (ribonucleic acid), which is 29 903 nucleotides long and encodes for just 10 genes, making it the longest known RNA virus genome while being a hundred thousand times smaller than the human genome. The complete sequence was published on January 11, 2020. Human-to-human transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was confirmed on January 11, 2020. As of today, more than 180 million people have been infected by the new coronavirus and probably more than 10 million people (officially) have died from Covid-19.

    Michel Claessens is the author of “The Science and Politics of Covid-19” (Springer, 2021). A scientist and journalist, he works for the European Commission and teaches at the University of Brussels.

    Contact michel_claessens@yahoo.fr, @M_Claessens, +33-6-22887707

    [1] World Health Organization, The top 10 causes of death, 9 December 2020, https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/the-top-10-causes-of-death

  • AI is changing how newsrooms work: here’s what that will mean for science journalists

     By Mico Tatalovic,                                                                                                                                           Chairman of the Association of British Science Writers

    As artificial intelligence gets ever better and gets applied to all aspects of newsroom work, science journalism will change, too. The nature of our daily work will change and should be prepared for this.

    AI bots already write news, fact check, promote our stories, and assist journalists. Will their advent mean science reporters will become redundant, or will it upgrade how well we can work, making us into even better journalists? Should we fear losing jobs, or should we embrace the promise of this new disruption in media?

    Chairman of the Association of British Science Writers, and a board member of Balkan Network of Science Journalists, Mico Tatalovic, discusses these issues in a new editorial published in the Journal of Science Communication https://jcom.sissa.it/archive/17/01/JCOM_1701_2018_E

    Some of the issues were discussed at the 4th Kavli Symposium on science journalism was held 19-21 February in Austin, Texas. The conversation will continue at UK Conference of Science Journalists, in London, UK, on 16 October 2018.

    Read the JCOM editorial here

     

    About Mico Tatalovic:

    Chairman of the Association of British Science Writers

    Knight Science Journalism fellow at MIT 2017/2018

    Ba (Oxon), MPhil (Cantab), MSc (DIC)

    @MTatalovic

    Image: Shutterstock                                                                                                                                        www.svoboda.org

     

     

  • Who’s afraid of science journalists? Portugal’s scientists step into journalists’ shoes

    By Vera Novais, Observador

     The “Who’s afraid of journalists?” session at SciComPT2017 meeting, in Portugal, explored the tricky relationship between journalists, scientists and press officers by having them role play each other’s jobs

    What would happen if you put a scientist into a newsroom, and a journalist into a research lab?

    They might just have lots of fun and learn how to get along better, if a popular role-play session at a recent science communication meeting in Portugal is anything to go by.

    Around 25 of the 200 participants at the SciComPT2017 meeting in Coimbra, Portugal last month (12-13 October) attended the session “Who’s afraid of journalists?” (http://scicom.pt/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Programa-SciComPT-2017.pdf).

    It’s common to hear that there’s a communication problem between journalists and scientists. Most of the time it’s due to a lack of understanding or lack of knowledge of each other’s needs. The best way to solve this might be to put yourself in other people’s shoes.

    “Who’s afraid of journalists?” was a role-play session. Each participant, regardless of their work in real life, was given a task: to perform as a journalist, a scientist or a press officer – and a scenario – from a simple interview to a press conference after a fraud scandal.

    Participants got really involved in their new roles, eventually performing many of the most common stereotypes without even being asked to. After the role play, moderators and other participants discussed the role play, the behaviours and how to overcome some obstacles to communication. Most participants were particularly interested in journalists’ work: for example, how they pick their stories.

    I was moderating this session together with Júlio Borlido Santos, coordinator of the Communication Unit at the research institute I3S (Porto), and Ricardo Pires, scientist at the Centre for Neuroscience and Cell Biology (Coimbra).

    That same day, there was another session that brought together science communicators, press officers and science journalists. It was called: “What’s the role of scientific institutions’ communication offices: from media outlets to outreach, from scientists to society?”.

    Scientists told stories about their experience with the media and how important it is to know what journalists expect from them. The audience was also interested in understanding how science journalists performed their work.

    Both sessions were an indication that we can work together better if only we understand each other better, and such meetings can help foster better understanding.

    Next year’s SciComPT Meeting will take place between the 10th and the 12th of October in Figueira de Castelo Rodrigo, Portugal – Plataforma Ciência Aberta. This is the first centre to be part of the Open Science Centre (http://www.opensciencecentre.org/), with plans to engage local communities with science, technology and innovation.

    Photo: Vera Novais.

     

  • Ein Sommer voll Wissenschaft

    By Senne Starckx,

    Belgian science journalist

    28.08.2015 Heidelberg, Germany, 3rd Heidelberg Laureate Forum 3. Heidelberger Laureaten Forum Picture/Credit: Christian Flemming/HLF

    Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting and the Heidelberg Laureate Forum, summer doesn’t equal with relaxing on the beach or hiking in the mountains.

    Since a couple of years I always try to have some blank space in my agenda in the last week of June and the first week of July. That’s because I know this is the time of the year for my annual ‘retreat’: one week amongst the brightest and most inspiring minds of the planet, amidst the beautiful surroundings of little charming Lindau and the magnificent Bodensee.

    I don’t lie when I’m saying that by now I’ve become a regular of the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting. The last edition, which was held from 28 June until 3 July, was already the fifth one I participated in. The highlight of my stay – which again was bathed in the summer heat of this sunny part of Germany – was a long interview with François Englert, the Belgian physicist who won the Nobelprize in 2013 for his discovery of the Higgs boson. This year the Meeting was dedicated to the ‘Interdisciplinary’ sciences – a clever excuse of the organization to choose and invite the most interesting people from all scientific areas. For a science reporter this is a goldmine: as interdisciplinary means that everything is connected with everything, it’s much easier to find interesting stories that are no too detailed, specific or complex for a lay public.

    Although I have been in Lindau several times, I’m always struck by the organizational perfection of conferences like the Nobel Meeting. Wherever it’s a plenary lecture, an arranged interview or a social event, everything really breaths German Gründlichkeit. And no to forget tradition. While the economic crisis has cut deeply in many institution’s budgets, removing conferences’ garnishing like good food, enjoyable gatherings and entertaining and inspiring side events, this is not true in Germany. The organizers of the Lindau Meeting seem to live in another universe, where tradition and continuity with the past are more important than the hype of today.

    Last August, I went to Germany again, for a similar meeting: the Heidelberg Laureate Forum, which took place in Heidelberg from 22 until 29 August. The Forum is similar to Lindau because also here the brightest minds in a specific field of study are invited: mathematics and computer science – in which there are no Nobel Prizes to win. The laureates that are invited all have won the Fields Medal, the Abel Prize (mathematics) or the Nevanlinna Prize (computer science). Another difference with Lindau is that this event is rather young: the last Forum was only the 3rd edition.

    One of the absolute stars of the Heidelberg Laureate Forum – of all three editions – is Vinton Cerf, vice-president of Google and nicknamed ‘the chief evangelist of the internet’. It’s really inspiring to hear him speak, not only about the past – Cerf was one of the fathers of the internet – but especially about the future. His latest panel addressed how the original architecture of the internet handles modern regulatory fragmentation, referencing how global data streams now route everything from medical records to traffic for the best offshore betting sites without regard for physical borders. He tackled many hot potatoes, like privacy, net neutrality, big data and artificial intelligence. For reporters covering these ‘new tech’ subjects, the Forum is a must to attend.

    Picture/Credit: Christian Flemming/HLF

     

  • EUSJA Testimonials Find Science Journalism In a Serious State of Erosion

    EUSJA Testimonials Find Science Journalism In a Serious State of Erosion

    Precarious: Many sci  journos cannot live off  science journalism anymore (c) Antonio Calvo
    Precarious: Many sci journos cannot live off science journalism anymore (c) Antonio Calvo

    During the EUSJA General Assembly 2015 in Stockholm, delegates from throughout Europe assessed the state of the art of science journalism. It revealed a broad scope of definitions, also due to the variety of cultures. Despite of this plurality, the unique base of the profession seems to be threatened by erosion. A decreasing amount of science journalists cannot make a living off science journalism anymore. An increasing number is accepting offers in communication to make up for the loss. It was commonly agreed though that EUSJA, also in its long-standing tradition, has to provide a roof for both, science journalists and communicators, and at the same time start to enforce journalistic training!

    •  His country, by far not the smallest one in Europe, can feed only 15 science journalists, reported one delegate. This is the reason why his science journalistic association has passed a new constitution which welcomes communicators, PR people however are asked to leave. All in all, his association recognizes science journalism as a central benchmark of the profession, assured the delegate
    •  The representative of a significantly larger country observed a critically shrinking market. It allows only ten pure science journalists to make a living.
    •  To make sure that colleagues comply with the standards of journalism an association made up of 15 full-time science journalists requests its member to sign a code of ethics.
    •  Another association with only 21 members admits only science journalists, no PR people, but has a clear focus on being inclusive, asserted the delegate. That shall ease the tension between the two fractions, which in some countries has escalated to a kind of cold war.
    •  Whether science journalists are critics or loudspeakers was already debated at the very first ESOF conference 2004 in Stockholm, remembered an old-timer.
    •  A renown book author about a variety of scientific topics from an Eastern country, who took an active role in breaking away from the Soviet empire, recognizes himself in the first place as an educator. To be an educator and a journalist, responded his colleague from another Eastern country, is no contradiction. But for himself he rather would put the emphasis on being a watchdog.
    •  If independence is the key criterium of a full-blooded science journalist, one Scandinavian delegate wondered, how independent could a science journalist be, with all editorial strings, business-driven interests and controls by the scientific community attached.

      Science journalism is under stress (c) Goede
      Science journalism is under stress (c) Goede
    •  One delegate had principal reservations about current definitions. He warned that defining who is a journalist and who is not one and especially making the frame too narrow could infringe on the freedom of speech.
    •  Another delegate from Central Europe freely admitted that he could not live off science journalism anymore and observed that most members of his association engaged in corporate publishing and PR. He expressed however his belief and faith that both, journalism and communication could be combined and reconciled in EUSJA.
    • This opinion was reinforced by another statement, in which a former president hailed EUSJA as a tolerant bottom-up organization, a true umbrella which molded a whole array of cultural differences in Europe and gave them one voice.
    • The representative of an association in Southern Europe with more than one hundred members stated that only one third are active, many of which engage in PR.
    •  To set off the adverse developments in science journalism a former EUSJA president suggested that EUSJA should provide more solid training. This could prevent the step of many colleagues into PR.
    • Right, sustained another delegate, trying to re-focus: If EUSJA wanted to be an umbrella, it must provide a wide and robust roof, but for both, communicators and science journalists, however strongly emphasize the journalistic branch and contribute to its survival with in-depth trainings.
    • Another delegate regretted that many colleagues are double-faced, call themselves science journalists, but produce pure PR without recognizing, realizing or even not knowing the difference.
    • Increasing dependence on politics and increasing propaganda in the public media was the main concern of a delegate coming from a large Eastern country.
    • In account of these detrimental developments a colleague made a pledge for the dissemination of new survival skills (such as entrepreneurial science journalism).
    • All this made one delegate muse whether there is enough space in Europe to found a second umbrella organization which is solely dedicated to foster a culture of pure science journalism.
    • The last speaker stated that science journalism has altogether disappeared in his very well-to-do Nordic country, that 90 percent of the respective journalistic content relied on one single source and that the nation was rolled over by big interests.

    Formula against ailing science journalism: EUSJA must provide  a wide roof for  many cultures, definitions, applications (c) Antonio Calvo
    Formula against ailing science journalism: EUSJA must provide a wide roof for many cultures, definitions, applications (c) Antonio Calvo

    In the discussion of these statements it was expressed that the testimonials show that the profession, indeed, is under great pressure. One discussant proposed to make these testimonials the foundation of future EUSJA work and to derive proper strategy from this. Another one would like to take these testimonials to Brussels and demand urgent action, such as funds to create a new culture and rescue a severely ailing science journalism. As one participant concluded, condensing the statements to three points:

    * We have to make science journalism relevant again,
    ** keep up our professional skills,

    *** proliferate our ethical engagement.