Category: Blog

  • Atomium Culture’s official response to Jens Degett

    Atomium Culture’s official response to Jens Degett

    We received this reply to the recent post on Atomium Culture
    by the President of the Danish Association of Science Journalists Jens Degett
    “Atomium Culture and The Role of the Media in Responsible Research and Innovation”

    Brussels – 3 April 2013

    OBJECT: Response to post by Jens Degett published on 24 March 2013

    Dear Jens Degett,

    The inquisitive and questioning nature of journalists is precisely one of the key qualities of the current press that need to persevere in order to ensure the development of Responsible Research and Innovation as the EISRI Summit in Dublin clearly pointed out.

    However, on behalf of Atomium Culture I would like to correct some of the facts that you report in your blog that are in effect incorrect or not precise (in order of appearance):

    1) The EISRI Summits are NOT events organised by the European Commission (nor was the Danish Science in Dialogue conference an EISRI Summit). EISRI stands for “European Intersectoral Summit on Research and Innovation” and is an event that Atomium Culture organises every 18 months to bring together leading representatives from academia, media, industry and policy makers to discuss a key issue relating to the relationship between science and society. For the Irish Presidency of the Council of the EU, the Department for Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation decided to use this platform, working in particular with the institutions engaged in Atomium Culture in Ireland (Trinity College Dublin and the Irish Times) to develop the theme of “The Role of the Media in Responsible Research and Innovation”.

    2) Atomium Culture is NOT a media organisation. Atomium Culture is a Brussels-based international non-profit organisation that brings together in its platform leading universities (http://atomiumculture.eu/node/33), media (http://atomiumculture.eu/node/92) and industry (http://atomiumculture.eu/node/43) to promote knowledge sharing and “out of the box” thinking on issues regarding the development of a European knowledge society; AC was launched publicly at the European Parliament by the leaders of the institutions engaged and by V. Giscard d’Estaing, currently Honorary President. The Board is chaired by Felipe Gonzalez and consists of the representatives of all sectors engaged (http://atomiumculture.eu/node/63).

    3) The possible construction of an EU Science Media Centre is a possible project that Atomium Culture is assessing whether or not to promote. It was suggested as a positive project by the representatives of the organisations engaged in AC following the Expert Panel Discussion organised together with Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung in March 2012. At this meeting in Frankfurt, several external organisations were also present, representing different fields of science communication. Since then, AC has organised numerous meetings with the different stakeholders to assess how such an institution could benefit science communication in Europe. EUSJA has been invited and represented during some of these meetings.

    4) Our Executive Director Erika Widegren was present at the Odense meeting upon invitation of the European Commission and Danish Ministry. Further, Ms Widegren was present at the ESOF Panel on Responsible Research and Innovation together with Mr Waldemar Kütt, Deputy Head of Cabinet of Commissioner Geoghegan-Quinn and Mr Uffe Toudal Pedersen, Permanent Secretary of the Danish Ministry of Science, Innovation and Higher Education.

    5) The conference topics, speaker list and material was prepared by the Conference Coordination Committee and the European Commission. The Conference Coordination Committee included representatives from Atomium Culture, the Irish Department of Jobs, Enterprise and Innovation, Trinity College Dublin and The Irish Times.

    6) Speakers at the conference included leaders and key representatives from academia, media, industry and policy makers (including the President of EUSJA Barbara Drillsma and President Emeritus Istvan Palugyai). The selection of speakers was done upon suggestion of all partners engaged in the conference and represented all different stakeholders and brought to the table the different perspectives of the debate. Full list of speakers can be found on http://eisri-summit.eu/programme-2/

    7) The aims of the Summit are clearly defined as:
    – Continue the conversation initiated during the “Science in Dialogue”, a Conference held during the Danish presidency to develop a European model for Responsible Research and Innovation;
    – Explore the role of media in the European model for Responsible Research and Innovation;
    – Facilitate the formation of professional networks, knowledge sharing, and exchange of best practices;
    – Come up with concrete recommendations on what has to be done in the short term at a European level to reach the long term objectives of smart, inclusive and sustainable growth.

    In addition to the above corrections, Atomium Culture would further like to clarify that it is not a media organisation involved directly in science communication. What Atomium Culture does is bring together academia, media and industry to assess some of the underlying issues and support the development of innovative projects that can benefit the organisations engaged in the platform.

    AC is a strong proponent of the fact that “Europe already has excellent research universities, media organisations and industry”. AC works with the newspapers engaged in the platform, in particular with our Editorial Committee (composed of the chief science editors of Der Standard, El País, Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung, The Irish Times and Il Sole 24 Ore) to find new ways of collaboration to benefit all partners and in particular the relationship between science and society.

    From the reaction of members of EUSJA during several of the meetings organised by Atomium Culture in 2012–2013 we understand that there is a clear concern by some of the members of EUSJA relating to some of the new projects that Atomium Culture is promoting—in particular, the development of an EU Science Media Centre.

    We believe that these fears are unfounded and would welcome, as stated several times to members of EUSJA, to have an open and constructive discussion on these themes and to see how EUSJA could play a role in the development of this institution. The EU SMC would be developed to support journalists across Europe so the input of EUSJA is certainly very welcome. Fabio Turone has already voiced some of the concerns and Atomium Culture is doing its utmost to develop a project that reflects the different needs and concerns of ALL stakeholders. There is strong support for the development of an EU Science Media Centre by academic institutions, established media, industry, NGOs and policy makers, each of which sees the usefulness of such an institution.

    Again, thank you for your comments and we hope that EUSJA and its members will welcome the suggestion for a concrete and direct discussion on these themes in the future.

    Renato Tagliaferro
    Director of External Relations
    Atomium Culture

  • Kafkaesque? Not Prague’s Science! by Wolfgang C. Goede

    Kafkaesque? Not Prague’s Science! by Wolfgang C. Goede

    EUSJA GA Prag 2013 063During Franz Kafka’s time, Prague was supposedly quite a Kafkaesque place with lots of secrets behind the doors of its ancient buildings. Communism did not help much to disperse this reputation. Now modern science is fundamentally changing the city’s fame and vibrations. During an EUSJA study trip to the Vlatava capital, laboratories turned into public show cases. Hands-on science with in-depth explanations, impressive experiments and open discussions with accessible researchers demonstrated that Prague ambitiously reaches out to become a major player in the world elite of science.

    Alas! No charming old buildings any more. Instead a brand new campus with the most modern labs, English is spoken everywhere, a liberal spirit prevails. The physicist Ivan Kasik takes us around the Institute of Photonics and Electronics. Here we are at the forefront of the communication revolution. Kasik and his team are cooperating with leading research organizations throughout Europe to improve the performance of glass fibers. The scientist knows how sci journs tick. In very basic terms, with striking examples and little experiments he explains how this type of glass works and lays out the challenges ahead in fiber engineering.

    Principally the transparent strings are pipes which transport light waves, which are coded communication signals. With many tricks such as purifying the glass and applying special coatings the material’s efficiency is being boosted. As a carrier of our worldwide communication, highly efficient glass fibers are becoming a prime commodity. Cities and countries with a high fiber index such as Sweden or South Korea belong to the leading high-tech nations. “If we want to further increase the speed of the internet, we have to change the wave length from visible to near infrared”, says Kasik. That would, in the long run, ensure a “fantastic data stream”, he adds.EUSJA GA Prag 2013 071

    There are many other applications though. Glass fibers can be used as lasers with the light more intensive than 200 suns. They serve to weld and to cut. Also fibers are viable sensors and become increasingly important in chemical detection, emergency systems as well as medicine. Hopefully one day they are able to look into cells, however, they cannot detect cancer or HIV, Kasik corrects speculations which were expressed in some premature media reports.

    The production of the fibers is outright exciting. Glass is heated up to 2100 degrees Celsius and then threads are drawn, if necessary extremely thin, like “Angelo’s hair” spaghetti, says an Italian colleague. Another one wants to know whether nerves could be made from special glass one day. Kasik does not want to get into other speculations, rather stays on firm ground and demonstrates the production process. In his lab, a fiber of one kilometer length takes one hour, in an industrial plant only two minutes.

    Change of scenery. The geologist Pavel Bosak talks about another fascinating topic: minerals. They are our greatest treasure, he says and states: “All materials we use on earth come from the interior of our planet.” At the same time, minerals are a window into our past. They document the entire history of our planet and evolution. Since our earth has been exposed to so many changes, from steamy heat to extreme cold, he cannot believe in the threats of climate change. Therefore he considers himself a climate skeptic, he admits, a position widely not very well accepted, but geologically perhaps justified.

    EUSJA GA Prag 2013 097For its investigations, Bosak’s institute relies on a series of highly sophisticated instruments such as scanning electron microscopes, X-ray powder refractors, electron probe microanalyzers, superconducting rock magnometers. Looking through the optical systems of some instruments reveals most beautiful and mysterious crystal formations. The institute’s fossil studies contributed to cutting edge research, for example to explore the evolution of jump mechanisms of animals. Analysis of the Egyptian pyramids established the fact that the materials came from very far away – how, no one knows yet.

    All in all, Bosak concludes, passionately, that geology is a prime scientific discipline, which deserves much more funding. The financial situation remains tight, he confesses. Politicians don’t always understand the needs of science, he regrets with diplomatic politeness; and, may be, there could be more public debate about research and its goals, he hesitantly agrees with one participant of the tour.

    After glass fibers and minerals  the next stop are plants. The biology institute emphasizes a focus on medicine, for instance the development of anti-cancer properties and GMOs, genetically manipulated plants to be used as new vaccines. The highlight, as it turns out, is to peer into a cell and witness a cell division, almost just as dramatic as Hollywood presents these wondrous processes of life. On the other side, very reconciling the fact that biology also can do without expensive instruments and yet progresses, rather naturally by means of conventional breeding and crossing.EUSJA GA Prag 2013 108

    This, for example make apples more resistant against invaders. Many species like Red Topaz don’t require chemical treatment any more. Probes circulated around in slices reveal that the outcome is delicious. Photographs at the lab’s walls show how far this organic method extends. Apple trees have turned into vertical wooden columns which facilitate the harvest of the popular and healthy fruits. This all pays off. Licenses produce a yearly income of 200 000 Euros for the institute.

    The next demonstration is on a screen. Milan Hajek, Prague’s expert on microwave technology, apologizes: There is no space right now in his lab. Although rather dry and abstract, he manages to catch the attention of his audience. Drying books and valuable papers after floods and natural disasters is very difficult and so far has almost been impossible. His team deploys microwaves, so well controlled that they don’t leave any spots. The other field of research is street repairs. After this long winter period roads all over Europa are severely damaged. Microwaves can help. They enter the asphalt by ten centimeters and dry it almost instantly, providing the conditions for a swift repair.

    Then this study trip’s final visit: Microreactors which look like lego. Assembled and connected with each other they produce chemicals. Amazing, the purchase of one piece easily runs up to 10 000 Euro. But it withstands pressures of 100 bar! The set-up reminds of a little steam engine which children in the 1950ies used to play with. In the old days, they drove tiny saws and hammers, now they synthesize wash lotions, pills, dynamite.

    EUSJA GA Prag 2013 151The chemical engineer Jiri Kristal explains the advantages of this new production line: safer, more energy efficient, better control, “the way to go”.  A pragmatic, no word about the fiction-like perspectives: factories of the size of chips, which can be inserted everywhere, in bodies – may be also premature, although laboratories on a chip have already been state of the art for years.

    Saturday evening, after 6 pm. A closely tacted all-day marathon around Prague’s new high-technology campus at the outskirts of the city comes to an end. We look around. The scientists and their staff are less exhausted than the visitors. They really must like what they are doing and share it with critical audiences like science journalists. Kafka would have enjoyed the tour!

     

    LINKS:

    Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic: http://avcr.cz

    Institute of Chemical Process Fundamentals: http://www.icpf.cas.cz/en

    Institute of Geology: www.gli.cas.cz/en

    Institute of Photonics & Electronics: http://www.ufe.cz

    Institute of Experimental Botany: www.ueb.cas.cz/en

    Contact: Marina Huzvarova, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Academic Bulletin, Editor-in-Chief: huzvarova@ssc.cas.cz

    pix (c) Goede

  • Atomium Culture and The Role of the Media in Responsible Research and Innovation – by Jens Degett

    Atomium Culture and The Role of the Media in Responsible Research and Innovation – by Jens Degett

    Atomium Culture sent an official response to this post, that can be read here:

    https://www.eusja.org/atomiun-cultures-official-response-to-jens-degett/

    Science communications is not only a question of telling nice stories that fascinate the public in the best positivistic style. It is a very important part of an advanced society to have an informed public who participate in an open dialogue and the democratic processes behind decision making. Some may see science mainly as a tool to improve economy, but this is only one aspect of science and not all technological developments are beneficial for society. Therefore it is important that the public is informed, understands and participates in the debate about science and technology in society. The shift in European science policy from aspiring to create the best science in the world and instead aiming at creating the best science for the world was the theme of a new series of meetings (EISRI conferences) which started during the Danish EU-Presidency in 2012, and this vision is being implemented in the overall Horizon 2020 strategy.

    EISRI_2013_Dublin-responsible-media-Atomium-culture-controversyThe follow up meeting in Dublin, 25-26 February 2013 titled “The Role of the Media in Responsible Research and Innovation” was organized by Atomium Culture, a relatively new media organization in Europe, which wants to develop a European Science Media Centre. This new organization seems to be enigmatic in several ways. Its founder has no firm academic background, nor has he worked with science journalism or even science communication. The key executives also have a weak background in science journalism and communication. Yet, this organization is very well connected to former top politicians like Felipe Gonzáles and Valéry Giscard d´Estaing. In its short time of existence Atomium Culture has made connection to a number of newspapers, but what does this really mean? The content of most of these relationships seems rather empty. To me, their features in English posted in non-English newspapers’ web sites make no sense: readers can’t find them because those features aren’t presented anywhere else in the newspaper (whether in print or on the internet); English speaking readers already have much better sources for science news, even places where they can actually discuss them. This is an example of a top-down, one-way, obsolete, really poor science communication.

    The meeting in Dublin was also somewhat detached from the former meeting in Odense, Denmark. This may not be surprising as Atomium Culture was not present at the meeting in Odense at all. For some reason Atomium Culture was allowed to steal the picture of the follow up conference completely. Both the invitation and the conference programme were written more like PR material for Atomium Culture than an EU-Conference under the Irish Presidency. There were some interesting political statements presented at the conference sessions but very little time to respond and discuss the different conference themes. Even worse was the selection of speakers where a new age pseudo science proponent speaking about the influence of black holes on our minds was put together in a session with highly estimated international scientists. I was thinking during this event. What is Atomium Culture trying to achieve? Why are they so eager to work with science communication? Why was this organization given the responsibility to organize the EISRI conference in Dublin with the support of 400.000 € from The European Commission? Does Atomium Culture really have something to contribute to the dialogue on science? You may have a look for yourself at their website: http://atomiumculture.eu/

    Jens Degett,
    Chair of the Danish Science Journalists Association

  • Are we for sale?

    money1The conference came to an end with a great scandal. No other scheduled speech could be of an interest after the statement of a deputy minister for communication. He was invited to speak to the conference “Journalism in 2012” organized by the faculty of journalism of Moscow University. One could expect some boring address like the officials usually do, but the words of deputy minister broke an academician atmosphere in a lecture hall. “Do you really trust that the journalism has a mission? Then you are giving a wrong motivation to your students. Journalism has no mission, but busyness. Better if you will explain your students from the very beginning: they will do what their boss will say!”

    I have never heard  to conference such emotional and angry protests that followed after the statement. The next day it was news number one discussed in Russian media and different social nets. Of course, journalists felt insulted. Teachers of journalism were shocked. But there were also voices to support scandalous opinion. “Journalism is for sale indeed”, – these persons were saying, – “See, the newspapers will publish any stupid article if it will attract the readers and bring money, the TV channels will produce any false story to be attractive for advertisers and to take the lead over the competitors. Do you find pseudoscience articles every day or pseudoscience movies on TV? Since the audience pays for it, the newspapers or TV channels will produce it. Is not it for sale? Then is journalism busyness or no?”

    These arguments reminded me a discussion during the conference in science journalism we had last October to the North of Russia, some German science journalists participated also being invited by German-Russian Forum. There were a lot of interesting talks, but really hard discussion started when somebody mentioned that nowadays science journalism is nothing but science PR as science journalist works to sale the scientific idea. The audience immediately divided into two opposite groups. One (bigger) insisted that science journalism has its noble goals which are knowledge, progress and so on, the second (smaller) part was saying: it is a relic to speak of a mission of journalism. Media is for sale, thus it will be honest to admit that a journalist works for sale. If so, there is no difference among science journalism and science PR; those who deny it do not get the things evident. This group appealed to us: “Open your eyes! Everything is for sale. Journalism as well” There were Russian as well German journalists from the both sides of our hard discussion.

    Are we really blind relics – those who never agree that journalism is busyness or science journalism and science PR are equal?

  • Beat The Crisis with Science Debates

    Beat The Crisis with Science Debates

    German Science Debate Logo (c) TELI

    The Science Debate is on. The German Association of Science Writers TELI has launched a new platform of unique exchange at the Annual Reunion of Science Journalists “Wissenswerte” in Bremen. It shall link science and researchers, political and economical leaders with the Civil Society.  The initiators are worried that a lot of research is not being reported properly, especially its impact on the society. The German Science Debate shall resolve this impasse and open new avenues of dialogue.

    The German Science Debate rests on three major columns: the energy challenge and how to create sustainable and environmentally safe sources, health and nutrition, demography and old age. The initiators believe that these are the main issues in the coming decades, closely interwoven with science, technology and research. If these fields affect the prosperity and well-being of the majority of the population, then the society should have a word as to the purposes and outcome of this research. These means of participation are also crucial for the preservation and enhancement of democracy.

    The German Science Debate is zeroing in on current science news and trends, raising pros and cons, acquiring statements and contributions of key institutions and leaders involved in these topics and, finally, striving for public face-to-face debates. Ultimately, this dialogue shall contribute to the German election campaign, culminating in September 2013 in the election of a new chancelor and federal representatives. The first science debate was initiated already in 2009. It involved scientific leaders, politicians and members of the civil society. At the end, it could only conclude that science and technology did not play a role during the election campaign. They were hardly mentioned.

    One year later, TELI and EUSJA jointy presented the science debate for the first time on the European level. At ESOF Turin 2010, an international panel assessed its potential and pointed out its innovative elements. In some countries such as Estonia a science debate has been held since then. At the World Conference 2013 in Helsinki, EUSJA President em. Hanns-J. Neubert will introduce the science debate as a world-wide vehicle to bridge science and the civil society. Especially the European Union seems to be open to utilize this new tool of citizens’ participation. Science journalists are the natural moderators of these dialogues. They are not only essential for our future, but also create new means of employment.

    Science Debate 2013, London Pantaneto Forum http://www.pantaneto.co.uk/issue49/goede.htm
    Science Debate 2012/13 of the German Association of Science Writers http://www.teli.de/blog/
    Science Debate 2009 http://www.teli.de/wissenschaftsdebatte/index2009.html
    Result Debate 2009 http://www.teli.de/wissenschaftsdebatte/pm2009-09.html
    Science Debate 2010 (ESOF Turin) to 2012 http://www.teli.de/wissenschaftsdebatte/index.html