Category: Blog

  • Science is an onion with many layers of truth – by Wolfgang C. Goede

    Science is supposed to be objective. However, it is driven by interests and therefore susceptible to manipulation and distortion. A result of this was the denial of climate change. The Union of Concerned Scientists now launches a campaign to restore the trust in science and make it part of the democratic process.

    The truth always has many layers, in science sometimes a few more. That was the central message of Naomi Oreske’s book „Merchants of Doubt. How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming“. It reviews decades of activities of US scientists who discredited evidence that smoking cigarettes caused cancer and factory emissions led to global warming. Behind that were well-known scholars, practically acting on behalf of industrial interests. The nation listened to them, from the media to the White House.

    The result was that effective environmental policies in both, the United States and worldwide, were delayed. Even now, saving energy such as driving less or insulating their homes remains for many US citizens a rather alien word.

    The Union of Concerned Scientists UCS wants to change this. It counts 85’000 members, 150 staff members and is dedicated to scientific integrity. These days it launches a new campaign which promotes „Science and Democracy“. According to UCS program director Pallavi Phartiyal the activities are geared towards „the weight of evidence“ which means to point out to the public that science is based on facts.

    Furthermore, science has a context, a body, so to speak, which is the society. We want to take everything, she says, „that comes under the broad umbrella of science, technology and innovation and really integrate it into the democratic process, into the governance and policy making process“.

    This drive will mobilize the public, scientists and the media and emphasize the importance of science-based decisions in the policy process. This is the intellectual heritage of the enlightenment era, which the founders of the United States felt very much obliged to, stresses Ms. Phartiyal, thus also drawing a clear line between solid scientific thinking and creationists, who deny Darwin and believe in creation taught by the bible.

    The UCS campaign shall be implemented with public forums. They will gather all over the United States the stakeholders of a region, policy makers, the public, representatives of the political parties, media, the business communities and churches. The purpose is to discuss topics and issues of common concern, provide scientific evidence and come to science-based decisions.

    Scientific truth, even undistorted, is always like an onion with many layers. There has been abuse, of course, but it ususally gets detected. Even if scientific research manages to stay pure and does not get mixed up with selfish interests one question remains: Does the public go along with it?

    The UCS initiative is an encouraging one which welcomes and includes citizens in the decision making process. In future, this will decide about sustainable research and whether it can be implemented – with the people, by the people, for the people, as Abraham Lincoln said. This is the most important layer, the ultimate truth.

    Transparency and participation in research and science, technology and innovation, not only in the United States is opening a new chapter of democracy. Also Europe is heading into this direction. This EUSJA blog will periodically report on this increasingly important frontier and how we science journalists deal with it. Next week we’ll shift from Washington, D.C. to Brussels and take a close look at efforts undertaken by EU officials.

    Pix©UCS


  • Black and White – About the reputation of journalism – by Viola Egikova

    “He is a journalist, but he is a honest fellow!” Have you ever heard anything similar? No? Then I have to tell you an unpleasant thing: people do not like journalists. Just think what they say about our profession. Maybe the most innocent proverb on the topic of journalism is: “Lie. But so skillful that I believe it”. Why do we have such an odious reputation?

    “No surprise, answered a scientist whom I asked. There are just a few journalists who will not distort what you say. You speak with him and explain your research, but he will write nonsense for sure, because he may sell it better: the public is pleased to read tales. Why should I like a person whose profession is to be a liar?”

    This is an old antagonism among scientists and journalists. Maybe you heard another proverb: “If you speak with a journalist, you get a falsehood, but if you do not speak with a journalist, you lose your money”. Sure, we look as rather sordid persons in such a conception. But this is what scientists think of our profession doing an exception just for single journalists. Of course, this bad reputation is usually unjust, but it is based on precedents. And the precedents are sad, very sad. We have got one more fact.

    The most popular Russian website www.antropogenez.ru dedicated to human evolution posted an open letter of a well known scientist Dr. Maria Mednikova from the Institute of Archeology which is part of the Russian Academy of Sciences. She wrote about a documentary film from the Russian TV Channel “Culture” – “A City of Giants” which was broadcasted on May 4. That film tells about four-meter-bones, which, as they say, were found in the hills of Armenia. The authors argue that these bones belonged to human beings – ancient giants who used to live in that place.

    To prove the thesis the authors of that documentary interviewed the scientist. Dr. Maria Mednikova wrote in her open letter that the journalists manipulated the interview, cut it and changed the meaning of what she had said. According to her words, she insisted that no four-meter-giants could ever exist, it was against a scientific knowledge. But her words in that documentary were used as if she had proved the hypothesis.

    Since it was not the first time that scientists complained about their words being twisted, we again discussed this topic in our community. One may hear different opinions. Somebody says: a scientist must take the journalist to court. But in my country it is a long, boring and very expensive business without a clear result. Journalists say: let us create a black list of those who are twisting the facts. But this is not realistic: there are plenty of journalists who lie permanently, but feel perfectly.

    Scientists say: no interview any more. This also is not realistic; scientists need communication. Maybe better to show the text before publishing? I remember my discussion with a brilliant German science journalist who told me: he will never agree to show a text before publication. It is against the principles of journalism, he said. And let’s be honest with each other: journalists have to reduce and simplify to make science palatable for a large lay audience. Not every scientist would go along with this.

    Does this all mean that we are always between two fires – good principles or bad reputation? Can we stay white if somebody makes our profession dirty? Black and/or white, I have no answer to that question – who tries a response?

    The drawing is by Kaianders Sempler

  • Paris in the Springtime – by Barbie Drillsma

    Paris in the Springtime and what an exciting time of comings and goings.  I was there originally for the birth of my first grandchild, Camille Joy and then caught up in election fever.  What was staggering about the election is just how many young people appeared to be getting actively involved for the first time.

    Jaded taxi drivers did that Gallic shrug when asked what they thought. “Who was going to win, didn’t care.  Sarkozy is a crook and Hollande another champagne socialist” All they worried about was their taxes and how to answer American tourists who only wanted to know if Carla Bruni would leave Sarkozy if he lost the election.

    Sunday night and following dinner in the Place desVosgesmy daughter (Katy, not Amy who had just given birth) were swept along to Bastille where the true carnival atmosphere of election success had taken over.  Beer, wine, cakes, banners, balloons and acrobats packed the street and whenHollandstood on the steps of the monument erected on the site of Louis XV1’s prison, stormed by the people ofParis, there was uproar.

    Later, trying to speak with ecstaticHollandsupporters I asked what was important to them and if science featured in their lives.  The answer was sad.  Many of those who have passed the science side of their Baccalaureates are now looking for jobs in finance and banking. Although Hollande had pledged to close nuclear power stations all sounded proud of their energy industry and of the amount of electricity they exported acrossEurope.  They reckoned Hollande would close one or two run down stations to look as if he was fulfilling his pledge “But they are falling down anyway” they added.

    True the city is doing its bit to support science.  “Sciences sur Seine – La Science pour tous” Science on the river Seine, science for all, is running in the summer but although posters are displayed there are no dates, no details of what is happening, almost a token gesture.

    It is early days but most of the youngsters I met and spoke with were more interested in well paid jobs in the media, banking, living for the moment and not being involved in scientific discoveries and advances for their future. There are masses of magazines being bought inParisbut only once did I see somebody buy a true science mag like Science et Vie yet I saw scores of copies of Psychology ad Philosophy mags being bought and read.

    True, there are interesting times ahead of us inEuropeand I can foresee many more comings and goings before things settle down.