Category: Debate

  • How to prepare for the next pandemic

    This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is maski1.jpg

    The Science and Politics of Covid-19 (Springer, 2021) is one of the first popular science books published on the ongoing pandemic. Combining scientific rigour and journalistic style, the book retraces the history and the management of the pandemic in several countries. It draws upon lessons learned during the crisis, discusses the emergence of “science politics,” and answers the question: why has science failed?

    This image has an empty alt attribute; its file name is cover-1.jpg

    Everything we have seen about the Covid-19 outbreak corroborates with Rudolf Virchow, the 19th century father of pathological anatomy when he said that “an epidemic is a social phenomenon with some medical aspects.” The biggest fear since World War II, the coronavirus pandemic highlighted mistakes in government strategies and scientific research. Based on the latest research and interviews with experts from China, France, the United Kingdom, the United States and other countries, this popular science book provides an insider’s view on this major crisis which tells us a lot about the relations between science and society.

    In Short Covid-19 came out of the blue. On January 2, 2020, WHO issued a global alert on the emergence of several cases of “pneumonia of unknown cause” in Wuhan, China. Except in Beijing, most governments did not show any panic and merely set up a daily monitoring of the incubating epidemic. Donald Trump mocked the “Chinese virus” and claimed that “everything is under control.” This story is about a collective failure. Some of the most scientifically advanced countries have the highest Covid-19 mortality. With probably more than 10 million deaths as of today, the new coronavirus caused a rise of 20% in the annual number of deaths worldwide[1].

    Why has Science failed? Although most governments based their Covid-19 strategy on science, scientists failed to have a decisive influence on decision-makers—except in China—, which created genuine “time bombs.” The accelerated development of vaccines does not erase past months’ errors. More worryingly, experts themselves acknowledge that they did not rise to the challenge. Covid-19 also highlighted the weakness of democratic regimes and the power of technocapitalism. The “politics” of science came frontstage during the crisis, unveiling links between the production of science and the private sector, personal struggles among researchers who strive for recognition and authority, and the intermingling of science with politics.

    What Did We Learn? Here are 10 messages and recommendations developed in the book:

    1. Politicians and scientists have a shared responsibility for the mismanagement of the crisis. Many experts acknowledge that they did not rise to the challenge and underestimated the contagiousness of the virus and the dangerousness of the disease
    2. A major political mistake was that countries pulled down their blinds, locked their doors, and promoted national approaches rather than international cooperation
    3. We are not certain that SARS-CoV-2 originated in China as the coronavirus was already circulating in Europe in early December 2019 (at least in France and Italy)
    4. We did not learn the lessons from previous epidemics. Countries that have performed the best are those that implemented non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) as soon as possible. Speed is everything
    5. Mismanagement, miscommunication and incomprehensible delays led to genuine “time bombs.” Prevention of an epidemic does not start when the epidemic starts
    6. Expert committees should not be created “ex nihilo” but attached to the competent administration departments in order to secure decision processes and communication
    7. The crisis accelerated the development of “science politics” at an unprecedented scale, unveiling the links between the production of science and the private sector, the intermingling of science with politics and the political objectives of some experts
    8. The overall mismanagement also reflects the importance of overspecialisation and miscommunication, which has become a way of life in our society
    9. Despite rapid advances on vaccines, the pandemic will not end before several months or years have passed. Herd immunity may never be reached
    10. The resistance to masks and vaccines show that scientific knowledge disseminates slowly. It is now time for political distancing to put the basics first: develop science, fight ignorance.

    Background Covid-19 is the disease created by a new coronavirus, SARS-CoV-2, which appeared at the end of 2019. The virus’ genome is contained in a single strand of RNA (ribonucleic acid), which is 29 903 nucleotides long and encodes for just 10 genes, making it the longest known RNA virus genome while being a hundred thousand times smaller than the human genome. The complete sequence was published on January 11, 2020. Human-to-human transmission of SARS-CoV-2 was confirmed on January 11, 2020. As of today, more than 180 million people have been infected by the new coronavirus and probably more than 10 million people (officially) have died from Covid-19.

    Michel Claessens is the author of “The Science and Politics of Covid-19” (Springer, 2021). A scientist and journalist, he works for the European Commission and teaches at the University of Brussels.

    Contact michel_claessens@yahoo.fr, @M_Claessens, +33-6-22887707

    [1] World Health Organization, The top 10 causes of death, 9 December 2020, https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/the-top-10-causes-of-death

  • Welcome to Confession Session!

    Confession Session at Exsite 2017 Porto: Amparo Pino Leyman with the throwable microphone, blue cube (c) Mikko Myllykoski

    Science Cafés have become pretty boring. Exciting new dialogue formats needs the world. Here come the Finns with: Confession Session. Mikko Myllykoski,  president of the Finnish science journalists FASEJ and director of the Finnish Science Center Heureka explains it: Learn from your mistakes!

    Noel Jackson, Center for Life, Newcastle, confessing (c) Mikko Myllykoski

    Confession sessions are a new creation to enhance interactive and participative workshops. The roll-out occured at ECSITE 2016 Graz, a conference platform for science communicators, mostly engaged in museums and science centers. Mikko introduced it to the conference along with his Dutch colleague Ilse van Zeeland. She invented the name.

    THROWABLE MICROPHONE

    Mikko brought the throwable microphone to the concept, which is a blue cube made of foam. “Very good for confessing, because the soft fabric absorbs your sweat (and tears) and you can squeeze it, if that helps to calm your nerves down”, believes Mikko.

    Confessing around seven cardinal sins (c) Maren Schüpphaus

    Like with all great inventions, the idea is simple. The session creates an atmosphere which induces attendees to share their mistakes. This is a bit therapeutic, relieves the confessing person and, above all, the session offers a unique learning opportunity for all participants. This helps to develop a community spirit and professional identity. The dynamics bridge seasoned professionals with younger colleagues and promote the message:

    We all make mistakes and that is not the problem. “The problem is, if we don’t learn from them”, says Mikko

    SEVEN CARDINAL SINS

    In 2017, Mikko experimented with the session at EXSITE 2017 Porto, using a twist: The confessions were centered around the seven cardinal sins. Mikko’s Mexican colleague Amparo Pino Leyman helped him with the session. At the European Conference for Science Journalists ECSJ 2017 in Copenhagen, he repeated the session with his Finnish colleague Ulla Järvi in a similar fashion. Confessors were rewarded with bitter but tasty Finnish licorice. Some of these sessions turned out magnets and attracted large audiences of one hundred people.

    Mikko Myllykoski (center) with Ulla Järvi at ECSJ Copenhagen (c) Maren Schüpphaus

    Mikko points out one important prerequisite for a successful confession session. It’s important to identify a few colleagues who are willing to join in and perform a confession. “If we can get started with some five solid and entertaining stories, the rest should be easy”, he assures.

    ON STAGE IN NEW ZEALAND

    Please save the date: At PCST 2018 Dunedin/New Zealand, 4 to 6 April, Mikko and colleagues will run the first international confession session in 2018!

  • Shooting Star: Easy-To-Read – How to Write it

    Shooting Star: Easy-To-Read – How to Write it

    It’s a real shooting star: The new writing format emerges wherever you look throughout Europe and the world. With new job opportunities for science journalists!

    At the European Conference of Science Journalists ECSJ 2017 in Copenhagen, Hamburg-based trainer Ilse Furian showed examples from Germany, UK, Sweden.

    RAPID TEXT NAVIGATION

    She explained why an increasing percentage of adults need plain languages and easy-to-read formats. Some of the reasons, for example: With the advance of the internet, people write and read less and gradually lose their writing and reading skills. This relates particularly to complex content such as in science and technology.

    Hajo Neubert, Hamburg-based science journalist, explained the relevance of “easy to read and write” for journalists: easy navigation through press releases. A good reason why communication departments of scientific outlets should make an effort to professionalize in this field because they reach more interested people.

    EASY DOES IT

    Writing a text in easy language was the main interest of the 25 participants of this session. Ana Crespo and Elisabet Serra, both experts of the Associació Lecturafácil based in Barcelona, introduced examples of their work for the city of Barcelona, e.g. about health care, and explained  the rules for Easy-to-Read: short sentences, easy vocabulary, plenty of paragraphs, among others.

    Ana Crespo and Elisabet Serra (©Neubert)
    Easily stated – difficult in practice. This was the experience of the participants when they had tried to translate brief scientific texts into easy English. However, it was worthwhile for them to know about it. Especially since the number of news media, broadcasts, even books in easy-formats is rapidly increasing, not to mention official publications by government agencies. They all need to be translated and many employ journalists to do the job.

    Easy to read British Times (c) Times

    DEMOCRATIC RIGHT FOR EVERYONE

    In  democratic societies, there is a right of information for everyone. This is especially crucial for people with reading or learning disabilities.  Their lobbies and pressure made Easy-to-Read became a shooting star.

     

    SESSION FACILITATORS

    Hanns-J. Neubert
    Ana Crespo, Elisabet Serra, Asociacion lecturafacil, Barcelona
    Ilse Furian

    MORE INFOS

    Video “Acces to information”

    Report Information and Training Session EASY LANGUAGE (in German on German) at General Assembly of German Science Writers TELI 2017 in Munich

    MANUAL WITH RULES AND PRACTICES
    170614 Easy-to-Read Association

  • Make scientific facts great again. What Europe can do about it!

    Make scientific facts great again. What Europe can do about it!

    In recent years the world has seen a surge of populist movements that deny or distort scientific facts. Europe is not immune to these developments as can be seen in electoral results from all corners of the continent, West and East, North and South. The session will discuss the reasons for these developments and discuss strategies to put scientific evidence back into its rightful place in political and societal debates in Europe. A session submitted to the European Conference of Science Journalists 2017 Copenhagen by the European Commission, facilitated by Johannes Klumpers, Directorate General Research & Innovation, moderated by Wolfgang Chr. Goede, International Science Journalist, German Science Writers TELI, World Federation of Science Journalists WFSJ.

    BE AWARE OF THE DARK MIDDLE AGES
    Wolfgang Chr. Goede

    The common ground for this session and panel is the International Science March last April. As the moderator outlined in his introduction, “many of us have participated in this in our respective countries”. This is a historic and political landmark. For the first time in history scientists throughout the world took to the streets to demand scientific truth and evidence.

    The political background: Post-truth and alternative facts, plainly speaking lies attributed to last year’s US presidential campaign, the victor Donald Trump and the current US administration. The has culminated most recently in the pull-out of the US from the Paris climate agreement, denying all scientific evidence that carbondioxide contribute to global warming and needs to be cut down.

    Parallel to this development in the US is the populist rise in Europe, Hungary, Netherlands, Germany, France and UK: Brexit occurred on not substantiated information, rather emotions than facts and evidence.

    Overall, western democracies are at risk to fall back into the pre-enlightenment era, not to say into dark middle ages.

    The statements of four distinguished panelists follow.

    DEFENDING SCIENTIFIC FACTS IN EUROPEAN POLITICS: A REPORT FROM THE BATTLEFIELD
    Angelika Mlinar, Member of the European Parliament , Austria, Liberal Party

    Today media play an important role in the political environment and it is not always easy to make politics appealing for headlines by pointing out facts and evidence. It became especially difficult in recent years, where some political forces and part of the media became less reluctant to use wrong or partly-wrong information -making a politician’s effort to use accurate research results and facts even more crucial.

    However, with social media news are spreading much faster than ever before. When fake news articles or any piece of information is posted on Facebook, Twitter, etc. it is basically impossible to revoke it. It can get shared, included in other postings and repeated by anyone, including politicians. Fake news, spread on purpose, do usually not include (too) many scientific facts, but target the emotions of the individual. This is what makes it hard to counter their arguments. People seem not really open to purely scientific and logical arguments. Combing facts with emotions might therefore be one possible strategy to promote a positive image for fact-based policy-making.

    There are several ways to promote and defend scientific facts in the political environment. It is never easy to change a person’s opinion on a matter though. Especially if it is grounded on an emotional reasoning. However, it is essential for us politicians and policy-makers to base our decisions on proven facts rather than the piece of information that is most comfortable for our work. That is why we will continue our work to promote and propose scientific evidence as the foundation for our policy proposals.

    Examples to elaborate on include:

    • The recently resurfacing discussion on parents refusing to get their children vaccinated – Italy being one of the latest examples of a strict intervention based on scientific results by introducing mandatory vaccination for children.
    • Glyphosate and the way the European Commission handles/d the extension of the approval.
    • Climate Change or any other “fake news” story with Donald Trump at the center of attention.

    MAKING SURE THAT FACTS ARE NOT SCREWED UP IN BRUSSELS
    Sofie Vanthournout, Director Sense about Science EU (Belgium)

    Audience in Copenhagen’s Concert Hall (c) EC DG Research & Innovation

    There is a growing concern about a ‘post truth society’ and a belief among some commentators that the public is unwilling to engage with the evidence about complex policy issues. This risks MEPs and the media treating EU citizens as if they don’t care about the truth or accountability.

    But Sense about Science experiences every day that people do care deeply about facts and evidence in public life. On 21 June, we’ve brought over 100 people to the European Parliament, where 15 citizens each spoke for 1 minute on why evidence matters to them. They said:

    • We expect the Commission to use evidence when making policy.
    • We expect commissioners to explain their reasoning.
    • We expect Parliament to seek and to scrutinise reasoning behind policies.

    Frans Timmermans, first vice president of the European commission and parliamentarians from different political groups have responded to these demands.

    To make sure that MEPs live up to the citizen’s expectations and go on to seek, scrutinise or use evidence in policymaking, we will help citizens to ask for evidence in EU policy, through our Ask for Evidence campaign and we will organise a citizen-led review to monitor the ‘best and worst’ of MEPs responses over the next 12 months.

    AND THEN THEY CAME FOR THE EXPERTS – LESSONS FROM BREXIT
    Dame Anne Glover, Former Chief Scientific Adviser to the President of the European Commission, now Vice-Principal for External Affairs and Dean for Europe, University of Aberdeen.

    On the 23rd June 2016 the UK voted in a referendum of EU membership and decided by a narrow majority to leave the EU.  Only 72% of those eligible voted.

    The campaign leading up to the vote was remarkable in being almost completely evidence-free.  The Remain campaign failed to make a positive evidence-informed case for staying in the EU and the Leave campaign, supported by the tabloid press, flooded the media with misinformation about the EU and used false information to fan citizens fears about free movement of EU citizens in particular.

    Even now, over 1 year later, there is still a state of denial regarding the impact Brexit will have on the UK and even more worrying, the Government have not published any evidence regarding likely scenarios that might result.  This is an unprecedented example of how bad things can get if we turn our back on evidence-led decision-making.

    MAKING SCIENTIFIC FACTS GREAT AGAIN: HOW – THE COMMISSION’S SCIENTIFIC ADVICE MECHANISM SAM

    Rolf Heuer, former Director-General of CERN, Chair of the European Commission’s High Level Group of Scientific Advisors (SAM)

    The High Level Group of scientific advisors of the European Commission’s Scientific Advice Mechanism (SAM HLG) is unique. It speaks directly with the College of European Commissioners, and works with a consortium of European scientific academies which provide expertise rapidly, and on the widest possible range of scientific domains. It is supported by a well-resourced team in the EC’s Directorate General for Research and Innovation.

    Transparency is fundamental to the SAM HLG: members are independent of the Commission and appointed in a personal capacity, and the HLG only examines evidence which is in the public domain when producing its advice. Moreover, the SAM HLG is honest about uncertainty and takes care to communicate this to the users of its advice: this is particularly important when evidence is incomplete and when society holds strong views about the issues at stake.

    The HLG provides advice to the College having been asked to do so, but can also propose advice to the College. To date, it has delivered on request, scientific opinions for climate and cybersecurity policies as well as ‘explanatory notes’ on ‘new techniques in agricultural biotechnology’ and on issues surrounding the regulatory approval of ‘glyphosate’ as an ingredient in plant protection products. Each of these pieces of advice is being considered in the review or development of policies in corresponding areas. The HLG is presently working on scientific opinions on the sustainable use of marine resources and on the regulation of plant protection products. Shortly, the HLG will propose to provide advice to the College of European Commissioners on a number of other topics.

    (c) EC DG Research & Innovation

    All of the activities of the Scientific Advice Mechanism including the minutes of workshops and meetings, as well as all of the products of the HLG, including scientific opinions and explanatory notes are available on the SAM website.

    As to the discussion and results of this topic, the following highlights deserve bullet points:

    • Commitment and Courage: We all, but especially also science journalists have to try to do a better job in our daily communication and not be afraid to pick up on controversial subjects.
    • Recognition of the constraints of science: As every other profession, scientists are also driven by their values (Anne Glover)
    • More accountability: Scientists have to become better at explaining to taxpayers how they spend their money and what the research is good for (Anne Glover)
    • Science is no fake: Look at your smart phone and appreciate all the physics it contains (Rolf Heuer)
    • All in all, there is no pointing fingers at each other, we’re all responsible for our democracy and well-being.

    SESSION VIDEO
    https://twitter.com/hashtag/SAMGroupEU?src=hash

    All pictures (c) EC DG Research & Innovation

  • So you wanna communicate science?

    So you wanna communicate science?

    Professor Alex Gerber with Rhine Waal students (c) Goede
    Professor Alex Gerber with Rhine Waal students (c) Goede

    What needs to be narrated, if an oldie of this profession teaches decades younger newcomers in the trade of science journalism and science communication in general? A report of a three-day mission to a place, which was looked down upon as the boonies, but turns out an emerging center of excellence on the global academic map.

    The location: At Germany’s mostwestern corner, where her majesty the Rhine flows into the Netherlands. A brandnew campus, built on farmland and meadows, with a silo and a crane as conspicuous leftovers, reminders of the history of the city: Kleve, formerly a crude transfer site for agricultural goods, today a cutting edge research site and university, which hosts students from all continents. Kleve has jumped courageously into an experiment and has entered the stage of a knowledge economy. First impression: No hustle and bustle like in Berlin, Munich, Hamburg, lots of nature, relaxed and inspiring campus atmosphere, just like in Berkely or Palo Alto.

    (c) Goede
    (c) Goede

    The students: A group of eleven, one third from out of Europe, the Americas, Africa, Asia, the rest Germans from the state of Nordrhein-Westfalen. So to speak an interesting international cocktail. Many of them 2nd semester, very little experienced in science communication and journalism, still in their orientation phase.

    The curriculum: Basically open, but with a strong emphasis on practical work. I have books in my luggage, i.e. Bill Bryson: A short history of nearly everything; and printouts of AlphaGalileo news; and many ideas, such as to present TED talks of the shooting star of science communication, Brian Cox, how he easily chats about the wonders of the universe as well as the Large Hadron Collider. I hope that I always can fall back on my teaching experience at Munich’s People’s University. As a method, I use the participants’ knowledge as a unique resource which can be tapped like a treasure chest and fed into the learning experience. Would that work also here at the Lower Rhine?

    Sociometric Line-ups & Murmur Groups

    Rhine Waal: Where yesterday meets tomorrow (c) Goede
    Rhine Waal: Where yesterday meets tomorrow (c) Goede

    Friday afternoon: After seven hours on the train arrival and brief introduction, then we jump right into it. We do sociometric line-ups, which open a lot of communication, during which the students learn more about each other. And the teacher gets a profile, detects needs, patterns. Small murmur groups follow. They collect what the students want to talk about. Speakers of the groups present the results. A check list is being generated, which is the navigation through the three-day workshop. Ok, let’s get started!

    Miraculous Tischwasher: It is my goal that everything we address and raise shall be practiced in writing. No matter whether radio, TV, youtube, well thought-out and presented texts remain the basis of communication and journalism. One student has developed a what he calls a „Tischwasher“, a device which does not clean only dishes, but with the dishes on it the entire table (“Tisch” in German). This shall facilitate the cleaning process. Quite intriguing the technical aspects, the designs and ramifications for the labor market. Is it more than a gimmick? This participant becomes our expert. He presents his invention, the group asks for details and clarifications, then: 15 minutes, under lots of pressure to write the story, either as a press release or journalistic, as news or a commentary.

    Flip chart instead of powerpoint (c) Goede
    Flip chart instead of powerpoint (c) Goede

    The differences between media and PR have been defined before: In science communication, you are more or less your master’s voice, show the sunny side, while the journalistic part has to include other opinions, if necessary criticism and serves the public interest, indicates dark and rainy patches of the topic. Everyone produces a corresponding piece. Success!, everyone has scored. The foundation for the next two days is laid, so we happily can adjourn.

    Ethics, Onions & Kant

    Saturday: We take turns and ask how the participants have digested Friday’s lesson. Some say that they want more input and practical experience by the lecturer. I talk about 29 years on the science beat for a popular science magazine. Highly rewarding, I always felt like Columbus investigating new horizons, but at the same time lots of compromises were made, new technologies jazzed up, explaining them very well, skillfully wrapped into stories, but all in all with plenty of uncritical cheerleading.

    Relaxed campus atmosphere (c) Goede
    Relaxed campus atmosphere (c) Goede

    Generally, I emphasize, times and markets have dramatically changed, so students need to detect their own reality. Today employment as an editor is scarce. Very few have the luxury of long-winded investigations, as we used to have, up to one month for one topic. And I also give vent to what I learned about objectivity. Truth seems like an onion with many layers. Live up to Kant ethics, if you can and his categorical imperative.

    Bottom line: Develop your own business idea around your passions, become your own trademark, as Alexander Gerber, head and founder of the science communication department never gets tired to pronounce. Be creative and bold, but stay clean, regard the civil society as your constituency. And embrace the international scientific community. Gerber forged with the European Science Journalists EUSJA a worldwide coalition around the EU project NUCLEUS, which will come up with a handy tool kit for ethics.

    Exposés & Elevator Pitches

    Learn to sell with elevator pitches (c) Goede
    Learn to sell with elevator pitches (c) Goede

    Important note: Always focus please on the needs and experiences of your audience, not only in writing, but also in teaching. For example: The students are very knowledgeable about Egypt, its history, the myths. A recent investigation has shown that pharao Tut’s sword contained minerals of a meteorite. We develop five different angles to write a story, from the allusion that the Egyptian culture was triggered by alien influences and from outer space to the revelations of modern archeology, which ground the highly speculative elements.

    It is rewarding to find that the students mostly think in journalistic terms and that they want to confront nebulous theories with hard science. The presence of three native speakers (Canada, India, Zimbabwe) turns out very helpful as a means of amending and enhancing the English of the German students (and, of course, also the teacher’s).

    How to sell the stories now? The main characteristics of a proper exposé are developed, such as: an attractive title, an short and concise abstract, the envisioned audience, the interviewed sources, conclusion and message, deadline of delivery of manuscript, honorarium. Subsequently, we practice the pitching of stories. Participants present their hobbies, in only 30 seconds, and offer to write about them, with convincing arguments. This turns out to be especially difficult for the German participants. They are a bit uptight. The African participants do very well, a well-done mixture of information, relaxed postures with smiles and politeness. Remember: take it easy, do breathe and don’t chop your own head off; life is too short and way too valuable to worry too much about yourself!

    The Sea Weed Story

    Virtues of science journalism (c) Goede
    Virtues of science journalism (c) Goede

    Formula against procrastination! A full-fledged problem for many writers, including the professional ones. One participant suggested the tomato or pomodori technique. Proceed in small steps, but make sure you start and finish your introduction. From there on you proceed chapter by chapter. Nice, catchy word. Personally, I prefer to lock myself into a room and get done with everything without distractions; but will need a reward afterwards.

    Sunday: Touring around the city and the surroundings. Beautiful parks in Kleve, an ancient castle, laid-back restaurants and cafés, lots of nature and water, unforgettable the bicycle trip on the dike along the Rhine all the way into the Netherlands, only 25 km to Nijmegen.

    Monday: The students are curious about how to find topics for scientific articles. I recommend: Don’t wait for the latest edition of Science or Nature. Open your eyes! Themes are everywhere. From my Sunday reading during a rest by the Rhine I’ve brought back a picture, which features a housing structure made out of sea weed. We brainstorm around it. See weed is a delicious, nutritious and abundantly available food. Along with some genetic transformation – if this is considered kosher! – it can be enhanced to produce energy. So it fulfills the basic needs of a growing population on the planet. But beware of our largest natural resource, the sea: don’t (over)exploit it.

    I Didn’t Fall Asleep

    The Rhine is near (c) Goede
    The Rhine is near (c) Goede

    One of the prime activities of the workshop, as defined Friday, is to investigate Kleve and the Kleve Campus. This shall be today’s main task, with a focus on interviewing techniques. Jointly we develop the essentials. Not to take no as an answer, if the person you want to interview says no. Stay polite and try new angles, last but not least this interview could and should also be in the self-interest of your target person. Prepare a check-list with questions, but stay within the flow of the conversation, especially when new unexpected aspects emerge. Always dig as deep as you can, don’t finish the conversation, until you have the entire picture.

    Participants: Very international, four continents (c) Goede
    Participants: Very international, four continents (c) Goede

    The interviews are trained in tandems, then the students swarm out over the campus to conduct interviews in labs, administrative sections, with other students out on the campus. At the end the class delivers its final piece. Well-done. Lots of interesting information about the science of Rhine Waal Campus was gathered. In chemistry: If a substance is too smelly, you just add a molecule, so it gets fat enough and cannot access your sensors in your nose. Security, too bad, did not want to talk to the students. As a whole it turns out that some students feel isolated despite of many social programs, that English is not spoken very well everywhere on this international campus and integration still needs to be worked on – by and large a journalistic outcome.

    In the oral evaluation of the workshop, students welcome the exposure to practical engagement, some and especially the Germans miss more theory. My personal hero is one participant, the most active during these 15 hours, who said that the high level of engagement kept him going and from falling asleep.

    Thanks!

    LINKS

    Rhine Waal Campus
    http://www.hochschule-rhein-waal.de

    Professor Alexander Gerber
    https://www.hochschule-rhein-waal.de/de/user/7571

    Where the heck is Kleve?
    https://www.eusja.org/where-the-heck-is-kleve/

    Brian Cox TED Talks
    https://www.ted.com/speakers/brian_cox

    Nucleus@PCST 2016 Istanbul
    https://www.pcst.co/conferences/session/2016-04-26/141

    Nucleus Kickoff
    http://www.tjnk.fi/fi/workshop-intertwined-roles-science-journalism-and-science-communication

    For applied moderation methods check PCST 2016 “How to make your audience’s neurons rock!” -> http://www.pcst.co/papers/view/71 –> Download of the resume go to the foot!