Category: EUSJA and NUCLEUS

  • How can we align the “two worlds” of RRI and Media?

    As part of the NUCLEUS project, EUSJA will conduct a series of interviews with science journalists. The questions will focus on the experiences, attitudes and perceptions of science journalists, and the aim will be to understand how RRI principles can be imbedded into the thier work. We strongly encourage you to participate in the interviews.

    From www.mrmediatraining.com

    The NUCLEUS project is initiating an exploration of how science journalists as representatives of the media relate to RRI (Responsible Research and Innovation) in geographically and culturally diverse environments. The study will investigate what barriers the media might have to RRI and capture novel ways of embedding RRI principles into the work of science journalists and their institutions. Primary outcomes of the study will be to question existing standards in science journalism and to develop new demands for the future.

    EUSJA will play a central task in the study and the first task will be to conduct 20 interviews with science journalists representing our national associations. The interviews focus on the experiences, attitudes and perceptions of science journalists and will address the many different ways they work, what criteria are used to select news stories, how the public can be engaged in scientific debates etc.

    The outcome of the 20 interviews conducted by EUSJA and 14 more interviews made by other NUCLEUS partners will be analysed and used as the basis for a focus group meeting taking place at the European Conference of Science Journalists in Copenhagen at the end of June. During the conference, an in-person survey will be conducted by the partner from Rhine-Waal University, Germany. Finally, EUSJA and the NUCLEUS partner University of Aberdeen will wrap it all up in a so-called Field Trip Report.

    All science journalists in EUSJA are strongly encouraged to participate in the interviews. We will ask you 12 simple questions and you can answer them by email or phone/Skype, whatever is more convenient for you. If you are interested, please write to Gorm Palmgren in Copenhagen at gorm@palmgren.dk and I will contact you right away.

  • Social media to the rescue for RRI in China?

    Social media to the rescue for RRI in China?

    Science journalism in China suffers from both lack of interest and a top-down approach, with a focus on science literacy rather than public involvement. While traditional science journalism declines, the blooming of new online outlets has brought novel, promising ways to report on science

    By Berit Viuf

    Words like accuracy, independence, objectivity, impartiality and fairness pop up when journalists discuss ethics in their profession. In most western countries, there seems to be consensus about what is considered responsible journalism. But when we look to continents with other cultural heritages, the concept of responsible journalism doesn’t necessarily have the same interpretation.

    Thus, media in different political landscapes will differ, and good ethical science journalism might be perceived in a variety of ways.

    The last of the NUCLEUS study trips took place in Beijing, China, and the outcomes can be found in the Field Trip Report: Beijing RRI & Public Engagement (cell 2). One of the main findings was that RRI is a difficult concept to grasp, and that science communication in general is viewed very differently in China than in western countries, and that scientists are not as strongly encouraged to share their knowledge with the public. When talking about popularization in China, the focus is on scientific literacy rather than debate.

    Science coverage is diminishing

    When it comes to media coverage of science, there is even more pessimism. Even though science contributed to 20 percent of the Chinese economy in 2007, according to Xu Xiuhua, former science editor of People’s Daily (one of the largest newspapers in China), the coverage of science was negligible. And it seems like this tendency has not changed in the last 10 years.

    In China, the biggest media outlets are controlled by the government, and therefore communication about science is also part of science policy. Thus, science coverage in media tend to be dominated by news stories that celebrates new technology discoveries and portraits of famous scientists. At least that is the impression you get, when talking to journalists working in China.

    – The propaganda-styled science journalism remains dominating in state media, though professionalism has grown in commercial media, says Hepeng Jia, a leading Chinese science journalist now a doctoral candidate studying science communication at Cornell University in USA.

    More commercial and independent media does not prioritise science, as it is not considered interesting to laypeople – and therefore not to advertisers. It’s much more likely to find coverage on commerce, fashion and entertainment. The exception is found in stories that have a direct influence on people like air pollution and food safety.

    There are several scientific papers that enjoy some popularity in China. However, they are not targeted to the ordinary Chinese person, but mainly other scientists.

    Social media to the rescue

    The growing social media might be the future source for science journalism and science communication. Increasingly, research institutes like the state-approved NGO China Research Institute for Science Popularization (CRISP) are analysing data from online tools such as Baidu (the Chinese version of Google) to identify the scientific topics and information for which people are searching. This analysis is used by CRISP for arranging monthly meetings with stakeholders (which could be journalists) to inform about these topics.

    Social media also offers young scientists the opportunity to debate their research, both with each other as well as the public. However, institutions have to be supportive of this kind of communication, and a lot of research institutions are still conservative, with a tradition of having very restricted communication channels. Even so, various types of new media, from blogs to Weibo to WeChat, goes behind the formal mechanisms. And there is reason for optimism, says Hepeng Jia:

    – Digital media, particularly low-cost mobile media, liberate many working scientists who want to do science communication to get involved. Also, they help change the marginalization of science news desks in many traditional media. Thirdly, social media and their networking function connect science media and those more honest readers; It is always an unrealizable dream to get a majority of the public become enthusiastic readers of science.

    The rise of online media also creates new opportunities for investigative journalism.

    – Science and technology controversies spread widely thanks to the rising use of the Internet. And the public increasingly refuses the official scientific explanations in fields varying from GM crops, trash burning and construction of chemical plants to food safety, Heping Jia says.

    The downside of the digital media is that – like in the West – it has seriously affected the economic model of print media, Hepeng Jia adds. It leaves very few opportunities to do investigative science journalism, so what is presently reported is primarily in-depth interpretation of science events.

    Adding up to this is the strong censorship seen in China where social media is monitored. Social media might be a way to debate, but maybe not too critically.

    RRI a foreign concept

    In an environment like this, RRI is not a familiar concept. During the NUCLEUS field trip 27 representatives from science and science communication communities in Beijing was interviewed, and even though a few had heard of RRI, it remained a theoretical term. To the rest, it was a completely new term, which – much like in Western countries – was hard to grasp.

    – I haven’t heard of the term RRI before, but I am familiar with scientific literacy and media ethics”, one of the interviewees said, while another representative explained “I don’t think we have the same term in China, but I think what we have is similar. We promote science and convey positive messages around it.

    Especially the last statement shows that the interpretation of RRI differs very much from what is understood in most Western countries, but it does reveal, that China recognises a need for educating the public on scientific topics.

    The problem of lack of time – and confidence

    While research institutions in the EU and many European countries have built-in requirements for communication, with resources allocated, Chinese scientists are not blessed with such incentives. There is no motivation for them to go out and spend valuable time on talking with the public or with journalists, and there are no career progression incentives connected to communication skills. On the contrary, there is an immense pressure to perform and deliver results. Spending time on extra activities is often not an option, and is not looked upon as important or desirable. And also, there is the issue of literacy.

    – Many Chinese scientists believe that the general public is not scientifically qualified to interactively discuss science and technology issues. As a result, when science and technology controversies arise, the science community either evades answering the public’s inquiries, or largely talks about the case in jargon with professional arrogance, says Hepeng Jia.

    Another hurdle is the fact that Chinese scientists are not used to talking to the press. It is unusual to receive a call from a journalist, and many scientists are not used to presenting their research to laymen and fear they will be misunderstood. This is an important obstacle to overcome, if RRI shall have a chance to develop in China.

    CRISP – which is also affiliated with the China Science Writers Association (CSWA) is working on facilitating some of these obstacles by offering media training and developing guidelines to scientists on how to speak to journalists.

  • First EUSJA and NUCLEUS workshop was held in Helsinki, Finland

    The first Science Journalist Network workshop focusing on RRI and journalism was held in Helsinki, Finland on the 2nd of May 2016. Public engagement is a key to RRI. But is it the responsibility of science journalists?

    The first EUSJA and NUCLEUS workshop in Helsinki was well attended. © Gorm Palmgren
    The first EUSJA and NUCLEUS workshop in Helsinki was well attended. © Gorm Palmgren

    The debate was lively and engaged and brought up many interesting issues. Those of you who were not in Helsinki as part of the NUCLEUS workshop can sit comfortably at home and watch the whole workshop which was being streamed lived and can be watched here.

    If you still wonder what RRI has to do with science journalism, you can watch the video below where Gorm Palmgren and Berit Viuf explain a bit about the project.

     

  • EUSJA and NUCLEUS

    EUSJA and NUCLEUS

    Overview of the road map for the NUCLEUS project. © Berit Viuf / freepik.com
    Overview of the road map for the NUCLEUS project. © Berit Viuf / freepik.com

    NUCLEUS is a four year-long EU project. You can read more here.

    You are more than welcome to participate in debates, if you have information or questions concerning journalism and RRI (Responsible Research and Innovation).

    You are also encouraged to join the facebook group EUSJA and NUCLEUS and post any input or question you may have.

  • Dilemmas at work – NUCLEUS workshop in Manchester

    The EU project NUCLEUS is attempting to implement RRI (Responsible Research and Innovation) in research institutions around the world. It is still a question though, whether science journalists have a responsibility when it comes to RRI, and – if we do – how we can ensure RRI in our research and reporting. By Berit Viuf and Gorm Palmgren

    The participants discussed eagerly the dilemmas they encounter in their daily life as science journalists
    The participants discussed eagerly the dilemmas they encounter in their daily life as science journalists. © Gorm Palmgren

    Journalists can roughly fill two roles in connection to RRI: the watchdog of research and the bridge builder to the public. The watchdog stands outside and report on how well scientists are doing RRI, while the bridge builder works within the system, and makes sure that the public understands what goes on inside the lab, so ordinary people can participate in the debate of how relevant a certain line of research is for society.

    As EUSJA’s representatives in the NUCLEUS project, we wanted to know some of the dilemmas that journalists face working in a new media landscape. Before we can work on guidelines that can help journalists navigate in science and RRI, we need to narrow down the most common challenges for science reporting.

    In Manchester, UK, at the 3rd European Conference for Science Journalists, we led a workshop to discuss this with fellow science journalists, with the intention that everybody should have a chance to exchange experiences. Based on what we have chosen to call a “Conversation Menu”, we let the participants discuss at their tables before presenting one dilemma to a panel. In the panel was a freelance science journalist (Elisabetta Curzel, Italy), a science editor at BBC Radio (Deborah Cohen, England) and a scientist at EuroScience (Jean-Pierre Alix, France). The panel then commented and gave advice on how to deal with the dilemmas.

    These are some of the topics that came up:

    How do we manage as science journalists, when there is an editorial pressure for always being entertaining and fascinating, but sometimes there is also a serious and dark side to science?
    It seems unlikely to pitch stories to an editor about how science failed to deliver in some way. Yet that is happening all the time. How do we deal with that as science writers?
    There is too much talk about the watchdog role, and not so much of the importance of the scientific process and the society in science journalism. When you are very critical about science, you lose the positive aspects for society.
    We are faced with a lot of problems in the media industry: crises, double standards, bias, too little time and money. So, journalists often make use of press releases and struggle to be objective. How can we do good science journalism when we depend so much on communication officers?
    Science journalism often exaggerates and personalises messages to the audience and distorts the accuracy of the science. It has a big impact on the news, and it seems like nobody in the newsroom cares about how reliable a science story is. Don’t journalists have a responsibility of any sort?

    In the panel was from front to back Deborah Cohen (science editor at BBC Radio), Jean-Pierre Alix (scientist and board member of EuroScience) and Elisabetta Curzel (freelance science journalist). © Gorm Palmgren
    In the panel was from front to back Deborah Cohen (science editor at BBC Radio), Jean-Pierre Alix (scientist and board member of EuroScience) and Elisabetta Curzel (freelance science journalist). © Gorm Palmgren

    The main purpose at this stage of the NUCLEUS Science journalist network was to put into words the frustrations journalists can feel when reality obstructs their ambitions. But it was also interesting to hear the responses from three different stakeholders in the science media industry.

    The biggest frustration seemed to be that the pressure on the industry makes it difficult to tell the stories that journalists would really like to report about. As a result, reports easily become pretty, superficial and dependent on press releases. The panel seemed to agree on many of the problems raised, but also had some important input:

    “It is that balance of telling the audience about science. We do try to help people understand that science is a process. So part of what we do is to explain that. Another part is being a watchdog. Essentially we want to explain what scientists are doing, what makes them tick, because people in general don’t see a human face to science,” Deborah Cohen explained.

    “You can tell everything, because it really all depends on the story. Also when science fails to deliver. If I just say that Cinderella stayed home, there is no story. But if I tell the background for why she stayed home, it becomes very interesting,” Elisabetta Curzel elaborated.

    “We need journalists to translate science to a broad audience. If we just take information that was built in a scientific context and uses special wording and send it to the public, it will not work. The public do not have the level and vocabulary necessary to understand. So we need dissemination, and that dissemination needs to target different cultures in society. Good journalism should know how words are received in different cultures,” Jean-Pierre Alix stated.