Tag: Science Debate

  • Copenhagen Declaration

    Copenhagen Declaration

    ESOF 2014 Nano Debate 023COPENHAGEN DECLARATION
    Information Centers and Sound Data to Bridge the Gaps in Nano Technology Between Research, Industry and the Public
    Summary of Nano Science Debate@ESOF 2014

    “Building Bridges” was the motto of Europe’s largest science conference ESOF 2014 in Copenhagen. Above all, they need to be built to connect three sectors of society: science and research, industry, and the civil society.

    The science debate of the European Science Journalists EUSJA revealed many severe misunderstandings and a profound lack of knowledge about nanotechnology, two decades after the topic first emerged. More detailed information and more dialogue is necessary, in particular a broader array of inclusive, participative and collaborative formats, above all in the early phases of research. This is the essence of the Nano Debate which may be summarized in 10 points. They comprise EUSJA’s COPENHAGEN DECLARATION.

    1. Nano technology remains a research field with many promises.
    2. In many fields such as graphene it has not been able to show its benefits for electronics.
    3. One of the major reasons is that the scientific community is divided and the general public is only badly informed.
    4. These deficits shall be resolved by establishing national and Europe-wide information centers which provide sound data bases with detailed information, as unanimiously agreed upon by stakeholders and the audience during the ESOF debate.
    5. Transparency will be further enhanced if more nano-products are being labeled in a clear consumer language and at conspicuous places.
    6. Regular and intensive stakeholder dialogues and polylogues are needed to bridge the gap among scientists and between research, industry and the general public including representatives of the civil society and NGOs.
    7. A new participative culture of communication, dissemination and education which has been pondered for many years needs to be introduced at all levels of society.
    8. With these conditions fulfilled, nano technology may after 20 years enter its 2nd phase, its realization and the exploitation of its full benefits, in close contact and consensus with the consumers, taxpayer, voters.
    9. All in all, the nano example shows that the public needs to be engaged in the early phases of research, not only with nano technology, but in all fields of research, science and technology.
    10. This new type of cutting edge science will empower Europe to compete globally and to reaffirm its number one position in world-class science.

    And this is the background of the COPENHAGEN DECLARATION. The ESOF session “Expectations and Risks of Nanotechnology”, organized by the European Science Journalists EUSJA, had invited four major stakeholders to present their views.

    Dr. Markus Lackinger, nano researcher representing the Technical University Munich TUM and Deutsches Museum (German Museum); Dr. Steffi Friedrichs, director of Nanotechnology Industries Association, Brussels; Dr. Lone Mikkelsen, Danish Ecological Council Kopenhagen; Claus Jorgensen, Danish Consumers Council Kopenhagen. The debate was attended by some 60 ESOF participants, mainly lay people.

    The statements and their reception demonstrated wide gaps of misunderstanding and a profound lack of knowledge. Lackinger stated that “promises turn out to be unkeepable”, because they are hyped by the media and thus blown out of proportion. But he also recognized that graphene is a material with a very high potential, especially in electronics and he wondered why ten years after its discovery no products existed.

    One of the reasons is that even the scientific community is divided over this technology, admitted Friedrichs, ”but the benefits are too important for any country to miss out on”. Nano products could, among many others things reduce CO2 emission, replace toxical materials, lessen the consumption of raw materials. ”The responsibility must be shared by all stakeholders, in order not to stifle elements of our society’s  sustainability”.

    Mikkelsen was concerned about undetected environmental and health hazards “The unknown unknown” remains in the state of the “paralysis of the analysis” she charged. Science can no longer tolerate a misinterpretation whereby “no evidence of harm” is mistaken for “evidence of no harm”, especially in light of the soaring commercial success.

    In 2015, the sales will reach in Europe a value of two trillion euros, without anyone to know whether nano particles enter the human body and what kind of reactions they cause. Only in Denmark, 1200 products are on the market, added Jorgensen. The society can only benefit from them if stronger regulation is implemented. He demanded that products be labeled and the establishment of information centers with comprehensive and publicly accessible data bases.

    Speakers of the audience which had discussed the experts’ statements at roundtables expressed their concern that lay people could not find information about nano technology. “If there is no data there should not be a market”, concluded Dino Trescher, journalist and editor of a nanotechnology magazine.

    The alarming lack of knowledge was addressed in a wrap-up by Menelaos Sotiriou, associated board member of the European Science Journalists EUSJA and its expert on EU projects. The Kopenhagen debate showed that ”the public needs to be engaged from the early stages of research” he stated and thus “become a co-creator of knowledge”.

    The European Commission is asked now to provide means and set the stage to reach this higher level of communication and interaction.images

    See for more details Nano Technology Debate Report on the EUSJA website -> https://www.eusja.org/no-evidence-of-harm-evidence-of-no-harm/#more-2789

    Contact and more information:
    Wolfgang C. Goede EUSJA Honorary Secretary
    w.goede@gmx.net
    www.eusja.org

  • Which are the next walls to fall?

    By Luca Tancredi Barone,
    ACCC freelance journalist (Spain, Catalan)

    Berlin3

    This November 14 members of EUSJA were offered a grant to attend the Falling Walls Conference in Berlin – the international conference on future breakthroughs in science and society. EUSJA has been invited to this fascinated event not once, and the journalists always could get enough possibilities for interesting articles and useful contacts. Our Spanish colleague, ACCC freelance journalist Luca Tancredi Barone shares his impressions – both positive and negative. Photos: Raili Leino (science journalist from Finland) and from www.falling-walls.com.
     

    It was my first time at a Falling Walls Conference. After being rejected in the first round, when a colleague had to cancel at the last minute, I was able to receive a grant that covered the conference fee and one hotel night.

    The Conference has been truly inspiring for me. A lot of nicely presented speeches on cutting-edge topics, mostly on science, but also on economy, human rights, policies, start-ups. The invited speakers had been carefully selected, and their time slots were respected in an original and entertaining way: a professional mime would intervene to “convince” the speaker to cut it short when time had arrived to leave the stage. The general feeling was that this conference gathered many interesting people, both on the stage and among the public.

    I had a chance to talk with some of the speakers and met people in the public who shared their different background with me. Many journalists also attended the meeting, and it was interesting to meet them too. I am going to prepare some interviews I will also share with you as soon as they are ready. Tweeting during the conference was also entertaining, though I would have expected more interactions. The opening event, on Friday night, was at the Science museum – a very suggestive venue, especially at night – to hold a celebration. And the dinner was in another fascinating museum: the Communication museum. Very nicely chosen environments.

    Despite my general positive feeling about this event, which I plan to attend again in the future, there is still room for improvement in my opinion. First and foremost, the venue is not ideal for the number of people, many of which had to sit on the floor during the conferences. It was also difficult to listen to the forums, small discussions organised during the breaks, where three sets of the scientists talking in the previous sessions where moderated each by a journalist – all the same time in the same, concentrated area. This during the coffee breaks, so while people were trying to get to their coffee, all in the same space. This worsened during lunch time, with very long cues and not very abundant food I have to say. Certainly, not the most important aspect of the otherwise exciting day, but still, given the fact that the venue was in an isolated area, the risk of remaining without anything to eat was high if you were not fast enough.

    Most annoying was the fact that journalistically it was very difficult to perform the interviews. If you needed a quiet place to record your interview, it was impossible. Of the 8 interviews I planned, I was given access to only 4 people, one I had to figure out myself, and I was only given one short slot in a (relatively) quiet room. The rest had to be done in the press room, together with many other people in a very noisy environment. I believe something better could be organized for sure. Finally, despite the fact I had been invited to both the welcoming event and the dinner, I had been cancelled from both lists and had to ask to be admitted in. And, together with a good number of people, had no table to sit for the dinner, and had to dine standing – in the end, it wasn’t a bad experience: I shared the time with interesting people. And the president of Falling Walls came personally to say he was sorry and explain that the no-show percentage at the dinner was unusually low. Easy to forgive but still telling of a may be not too smooth organization.

    Last observation for EUSJA: I think that to better help freelancers, a contribution should have been given to cover flight expenses and at least one extra night – the events were during two days – even in a cheaper place.

    Robert KirshnerJules Hoffmann

    Anne GloverFALLING WALLS 2011 - Radialsystem Berlin

     

     

     

     

  • Roll-out Science Debate

    Roll-out Science Debate

    PresseClub Wiss-Deb 020At ESOF 2010 Turin EUSJA introduced the Science Debate as a new method to make science more robust, promote citizens’ participation and create new jobs for science journalists. During this year’s world conference of science journalists in Helsinki EUSJA president em. Hajo Neubert and EUSJA treasurer Priit Ennet delivered a progress report and demonstrated what science debates can reach on the international level.

    http://www.wissenschaftsdebatte.de/?p=3412

    However, so far  this format was, by and large, an academic one, until last Tuesday. Munich’s International PressClub sponsored the rollout, a live science debate on demography, mandatory retirements and pensions. Researchers, representatives of NGOs and the civil society as well as politicians participated to outline new models of employment.

    http://www.wissenschaftsdebatte.de/?p=3638

    In mid September Germany will have general elections. Before the electorate goes to the polls, the science debate model will be presented at a national press conference as a new tool for science and science journalists. This also opens the way to Brussels.

    The debate format fullfils EU requirements for outreach. With the launch of Horizon 2020 in the beginning of 2014 this format can become very handy, also for the new EUSJA projects. So please stay tuned, comment and help to make this model a European success.

    Debate English

  • Beat The Crisis with Science Debates

    Beat The Crisis with Science Debates

    German Science Debate Logo (c) TELI

    The Science Debate is on. The German Association of Science Writers TELI has launched a new platform of unique exchange at the Annual Reunion of Science Journalists “Wissenswerte” in Bremen. It shall link science and researchers, political and economical leaders with the Civil Society.  The initiators are worried that a lot of research is not being reported properly, especially its impact on the society. The German Science Debate shall resolve this impasse and open new avenues of dialogue.

    The German Science Debate rests on three major columns: the energy challenge and how to create sustainable and environmentally safe sources, health and nutrition, demography and old age. The initiators believe that these are the main issues in the coming decades, closely interwoven with science, technology and research. If these fields affect the prosperity and well-being of the majority of the population, then the society should have a word as to the purposes and outcome of this research. These means of participation are also crucial for the preservation and enhancement of democracy.

    The German Science Debate is zeroing in on current science news and trends, raising pros and cons, acquiring statements and contributions of key institutions and leaders involved in these topics and, finally, striving for public face-to-face debates. Ultimately, this dialogue shall contribute to the German election campaign, culminating in September 2013 in the election of a new chancelor and federal representatives. The first science debate was initiated already in 2009. It involved scientific leaders, politicians and members of the civil society. At the end, it could only conclude that science and technology did not play a role during the election campaign. They were hardly mentioned.

    One year later, TELI and EUSJA jointy presented the science debate for the first time on the European level. At ESOF Turin 2010, an international panel assessed its potential and pointed out its innovative elements. In some countries such as Estonia a science debate has been held since then. At the World Conference 2013 in Helsinki, EUSJA President em. Hanns-J. Neubert will introduce the science debate as a world-wide vehicle to bridge science and the civil society. Especially the European Union seems to be open to utilize this new tool of citizens’ participation. Science journalists are the natural moderators of these dialogues. They are not only essential for our future, but also create new means of employment.

    Science Debate 2013, London Pantaneto Forum http://www.pantaneto.co.uk/issue49/goede.htm
    Science Debate 2012/13 of the German Association of Science Writers http://www.teli.de/blog/
    Science Debate 2009 http://www.teli.de/wissenschaftsdebatte/index2009.html
    Result Debate 2009 http://www.teli.de/wissenschaftsdebatte/pm2009-09.html
    Science Debate 2010 (ESOF Turin) to 2012 http://www.teli.de/wissenschaftsdebatte/index.html