Category: Blog

  • Copenhagen Declaration

    Copenhagen Declaration

    ESOF 2014 Nano Debate 023COPENHAGEN DECLARATION
    Information Centers and Sound Data to Bridge the Gaps in Nano Technology Between Research, Industry and the Public
    Summary of Nano Science Debate@ESOF 2014

    “Building Bridges” was the motto of Europe’s largest science conference ESOF 2014 in Copenhagen. Above all, they need to be built to connect three sectors of society: science and research, industry, and the civil society.

    The science debate of the European Science Journalists EUSJA revealed many severe misunderstandings and a profound lack of knowledge about nanotechnology, two decades after the topic first emerged. More detailed information and more dialogue is necessary, in particular a broader array of inclusive, participative and collaborative formats, above all in the early phases of research. This is the essence of the Nano Debate which may be summarized in 10 points. They comprise EUSJA’s COPENHAGEN DECLARATION.

    1. Nano technology remains a research field with many promises.
    2. In many fields such as graphene it has not been able to show its benefits for electronics.
    3. One of the major reasons is that the scientific community is divided and the general public is only badly informed.
    4. These deficits shall be resolved by establishing national and Europe-wide information centers which provide sound data bases with detailed information, as unanimiously agreed upon by stakeholders and the audience during the ESOF debate.
    5. Transparency will be further enhanced if more nano-products are being labeled in a clear consumer language and at conspicuous places.
    6. Regular and intensive stakeholder dialogues and polylogues are needed to bridge the gap among scientists and between research, industry and the general public including representatives of the civil society and NGOs.
    7. A new participative culture of communication, dissemination and education which has been pondered for many years needs to be introduced at all levels of society.
    8. With these conditions fulfilled, nano technology may after 20 years enter its 2nd phase, its realization and the exploitation of its full benefits, in close contact and consensus with the consumers, taxpayer, voters.
    9. All in all, the nano example shows that the public needs to be engaged in the early phases of research, not only with nano technology, but in all fields of research, science and technology.
    10. This new type of cutting edge science will empower Europe to compete globally and to reaffirm its number one position in world-class science.

    And this is the background of the COPENHAGEN DECLARATION. The ESOF session “Expectations and Risks of Nanotechnology”, organized by the European Science Journalists EUSJA, had invited four major stakeholders to present their views.

    Dr. Markus Lackinger, nano researcher representing the Technical University Munich TUM and Deutsches Museum (German Museum); Dr. Steffi Friedrichs, director of Nanotechnology Industries Association, Brussels; Dr. Lone Mikkelsen, Danish Ecological Council Kopenhagen; Claus Jorgensen, Danish Consumers Council Kopenhagen. The debate was attended by some 60 ESOF participants, mainly lay people.

    The statements and their reception demonstrated wide gaps of misunderstanding and a profound lack of knowledge. Lackinger stated that “promises turn out to be unkeepable”, because they are hyped by the media and thus blown out of proportion. But he also recognized that graphene is a material with a very high potential, especially in electronics and he wondered why ten years after its discovery no products existed.

    One of the reasons is that even the scientific community is divided over this technology, admitted Friedrichs, ”but the benefits are too important for any country to miss out on”. Nano products could, among many others things reduce CO2 emission, replace toxical materials, lessen the consumption of raw materials. ”The responsibility must be shared by all stakeholders, in order not to stifle elements of our society’s  sustainability”.

    Mikkelsen was concerned about undetected environmental and health hazards “The unknown unknown” remains in the state of the “paralysis of the analysis” she charged. Science can no longer tolerate a misinterpretation whereby “no evidence of harm” is mistaken for “evidence of no harm”, especially in light of the soaring commercial success.

    In 2015, the sales will reach in Europe a value of two trillion euros, without anyone to know whether nano particles enter the human body and what kind of reactions they cause. Only in Denmark, 1200 products are on the market, added Jorgensen. The society can only benefit from them if stronger regulation is implemented. He demanded that products be labeled and the establishment of information centers with comprehensive and publicly accessible data bases.

    Speakers of the audience which had discussed the experts’ statements at roundtables expressed their concern that lay people could not find information about nano technology. “If there is no data there should not be a market”, concluded Dino Trescher, journalist and editor of a nanotechnology magazine.

    The alarming lack of knowledge was addressed in a wrap-up by Menelaos Sotiriou, associated board member of the European Science Journalists EUSJA and its expert on EU projects. The Kopenhagen debate showed that ”the public needs to be engaged from the early stages of research” he stated and thus “become a co-creator of knowledge”.

    The European Commission is asked now to provide means and set the stage to reach this higher level of communication and interaction.images

    See for more details Nano Technology Debate Report on the EUSJA website -> https://www.eusja.org/no-evidence-of-harm-evidence-of-no-harm/#more-2789

    Contact and more information:
    Wolfgang C. Goede EUSJA Honorary Secretary
    w.goede@gmx.net
    www.eusja.org

  • 2nd European Conference for Science Journalists in November 2015

    2nd European Conference for Science Journalists in November 2015

    Istvan Palugyai (l.) and Jens Degett, organizers of the 2nd ECSJ (c) EUSJA
    Istvan Palugyai (l.) and Jens Degett, organizers of the 2nd ECSJ (c) EUSJA

    At a press conference during ESOF 2014 in Copenhagen, EUSJA announced date and themes for the 2nd European Conference for Science Journalists. ECSJ is scheduled for 3rd of November 2015 in Budapest as part of the World Science Forum organized by the Hungarian Academy of Science.

    The president of the European Union of Science Journalists’ Unions Satu Lipponen described the organization as a viable NGO which for more than 40 years has cultivated independent science journalism across the borders of the continent. EUSJA has 25 member organizations which all in all represent several thousand science journalists throughout Europe.

    EUSJA President Satu Lipponen ran the press conference during ESOF 2014 Kopenhagen
    EUSJA President Satu Lipponen ran the press conference during ESOF 2014 Kopenhagen

    EUSJA President emeritus Istvan Palguyai explained that the Hungarian Science Journalists’ Association will celebrate its 25th anniversary in 2015. That would be an appropriate time and frame for the 2nd European Conference of Science Journalists, also to honor history and tradition. The Hungarian Science Journalists hosted in 1999 the 2nd World Conference of Science Journalists in Budapest. The “Budapest Declaration” was a milestone and laid the foundation of the World Federation of Science Journalists.

    Satu Lipponen noted that Budapest would be a very good choice, also because of the political situation and turmoils. “It will stress the necessity of independent science journalism”, she said. She introduced a whole array of potential themes, among them investigative journalism, narratives and storytelling, tools of data journalism, ethical rules and how to foster independent science journalism in a media world dominated increasingly by science communicators and PR. She also indicated a 3rd ECSJ. EUSJA is planning to have it during the next Euroscience Open Forum June 2016 in Manchester.
    EUSJA Presse Conference@ESOF2014 002The organizer of the 1st ECSJ in Kopenhagen Jens Degett expressed his satisfaction about a very successful event. It was attended by about 250 people, 40 of them speakers and guests. It was a low budget operation. The Danish Ministry of Higher Education and Science and the Otto Monsted Foundation contributed 23 000 €. (Conference details see https://www.eusja.org/past-meets-future-science-between-rock-women-hippy-power-report-1st-european-conference-for-sci-journs-ecsj)EUSJA Presse Conference@ESOF2014 003

    During the press conference Ms. Lipponen was asked about the European Federation for Science Journalism. A flyer of a new science journalistic organization had been circulated and caught members of the sponsoring organizations by surprise. The EUSJA president expressed  that there is little space for two similar organizations and that she had not seen a constitution yet. An invitation to join the EUSJA press conference had been declined, added Jens Degett. “EUSJA enjoys a long collaboration with European institutions such as Euroscience which founded ESOF and with the European Commission”, observed Lipponen.

    EUSJA Presse Conference@ESOF2014 004EUSJA, she continued, will carry on with its strategy process started during ESOF in Kopenhagen. It contemplates a virtual membership, constitutional changes and a code of ethics for independent science journalism (details see https://www.eusja.org/mingling-changing-critical-together). Suggestions will be submitted to the EUSJA members at the next General Assembly 2015. Despite of pending reforms one characteristic remains. “EUSJA will stay inclusive and not exclude anyone”, said Lipponen.EUSJA Presse Conference@ESOF2014 006

     

  • No evidence of harm = Evidence of no harm?

    No evidence of harm = Evidence of no harm?

    Roundtables: Audience discusses feedback for stakeholders (c) EUSJA
    Roundtables: Audience discusses feedback for stakeholders (c) EUSJA

    International Rollout of the Science Debate@ESOF 2014 Kopenhagen. Major stakeholders and the public debated nanotechnology. After 20 years, our society still lacks knowledge about benefits and harm. The feedback of the roundtables showed that more dialogue and formats are needed. A respective resolution will be presented to the European Commission.

    Four major stakeholders presented their views about ”Expectations and Risks of Nanotechnology”: Dr. Markus Lackinger, nano researcher representing Deutsches Museum (German Museum) and Technical University Munich TUM; Dr. Steffi Friedrichs, Nanotechnology Industries Association, Brussels; Dr. Lone Mikkelsen, Danish Ecological Council, Kopenhagen; Claus Jorgensen, Danish Consumers Council, Kopenhagen. The meeting was attended by some 60 participants of the Euroscience Open Forum 2014 Kopenhagen. The event was moderated by Barbie Drillsma, EUSJA president emeritus.

    Chair of the debate; Barbie Drillsma (c) EUSJA
    Chair of the debate; Barbie Drillsma (c) EUSJA

    Hanns-J. Neubert, former chairman of the German Science Writers Association TELI, had developed the format. In his introduction, he outlined that debates have been created to set the agenda on scientific issues and make recommendations to policy makers. They are run live, like the Kopenhagen debate and continued online.

    Usually the public is consulted ”at the end of the pipe”, he explained, when decisions already have been made. Science debates convey the direct exchange between experts and the public and aim at ”start of the pipe” involvement. Only inclusion and collaboration from the beginning lead to robust and sustainable decisions about science and technology.

    Debate designer Hajo Neubert and Industry Representative Steffi Friedrichs (c) EUSJA
    Debate designer Hajo Neubert and Industry Representative Steffi Friedrichs (c) EUSJA

    Why shall science journalists instigate this process? ”They have the knowledge, keep the distance and are observers of research”, Neubert noted.

    Lackinger agreed that science and media need to engage in more closely monitored feedback cycles. Unkeepable promises of science are often due to improper reporting and media hypes, he regretted. ”The right balance is the challenge”, he demanded. The physicist explained nanotechnology and used the example of carbon nanotubes.

    ”Research on graphene has become one of the hottest topics in nano-science”, he stated. While consumer products have not become available, even 10 years after the discovery, they continue to have a large potential for a new generation of electronic circuits and chips.

    Nano physics (c) EUSJA
    Nano physics (c) EUSJA

    Friedrichs described nanotechnology within a field which is ”pulled by the market and enforced by policy”. Despite of this tension “the benefits are too important for any country to miss out on”.

    Products made of nano-materials could

    • reduce CO2 emission
    • replace many toxical materials currently being used
    • largely lessen the consumption of raw materials.

    She assured that test programs are under way and ended with a pledge for more communication: ”The responsibility must be shared by all stakeholders, in order not to stifle elements of our society’s  sustainability”.

    Environmental concerns: Lone Mikkelsen (c) EUSJA
    Environmental concerns: Lone Mikkelsen (c) EUSJA

    Mikkelsen agreed ”that there may be benefits, but we cannot ignore the dangers”, she warned. Among the 12 lessons learned in 20 years she singled out the environmental and health hazards ”which need to be monitored”.  The ”unknown unknown” still persists and we remain in the state of the ”paralysis of the analysis”.

    She noted a misinterpretation of science where ”no evidence of harm” is mistaken for ”evidence of no harm”. Risks always come first, demanded the representative of environmental protection, especially regarding allegations that nano particles enter the body: ”We have to act on early warnings.” Friedrichs quoted statistics compiled by the European Commission which expects for 2015 sales of nanoproducts with a value of two trillion euros.

    Her colleague from the Danish Consumers Council Jorgensen supported her view. Regarding the hazards he mentioned new sunscreen sprays available in Sweden. They contain nano particles which evidently can be inhaled very easily.

    Claus Jorgensen explains consumer rights (c) EUSJA
    Claus Jorgensen explains consumer rights (c) EUSJA

    He continued that only in Denmark there are 1200 products on the market which contain nano-materials, among them many cosmetics. ”There is a lack of knowledge of these products”, he observed ”and nobody knows the risks”. Of course the society can benefit from nano products, Jorgensen consented, but ”stronger regulation is needed” such as labeling the products and the establishment of a national information center.

    After these presentations of five minutes each the moderator threw the ball at the roundtables. She asked for a discussion of the topic after which a speaker should present three bullet points with comments, questions, concerns. During this phase the stakeholders went from table to table and made themselves available to answer arising questions. The individual debates got under way without the aid of a special moderator and were presented afterwards  by roundtable speakers.

    Nano physicist Markus Lackinger discusses science (c) EUSJA
    Nano physicist Markus Lackinger discusses science (c) EUSJA

    Dino Trescher, editor of www.nanomagazin.net, stated as a result of the group discussion that more readily available data is needed to satisfy the public right of information. From his own experience with the topic the journalist added that ”the existing data bases have loopholes”. His conclusion: ”If there is no data there should not be a market.”

    The speakers of the other roundtables reaffirmed a general notion that there is not enough information and data available which the concerned public can access. ”WHERE do we find it?” was the overriding question. There also remains confusion, as added by other speakers, about the definition of what nanotechnology is: ”WHAT exactly do we talk about?”

    The chairlady summed up the feedback from the roundtables with the statement ”We have a lack of knowledge”. Then she turned over the debate to the stakeholders and asked for short responses.

    Lackinger responded that nano-material consists of particles smaller than 100 nanometers and products made of these are called nano products. This he had outlined in his presentation but obviously it is difficult to digest by even an interested audience.

    Roundtable report (c) EUSJA
    Roundtable report (c) EUSJA

    Making nano even more visible could help to bridge the knowledge gap. An example: A sheet of paper is one hundred thousand (100 000) nanometers thicker and one single gold atom is about one third of a nanometer in diameter (http://www.nano.gov/nanotech-101/what/nano-size)

    Friedrichs responded to the call for more regulation that cosmetics are regulated since 2009. Many products are properly labeled, ”but how many consumers bother to take a look?” she asked.

    Mikkelsen agreed that ”yes, they are labeled, but not regulated”. Local governments and the EU must provide more information and data bases. Jorgensen pointed out one important source of information www.nanodb.dk

    Final round: Dino Trescher (r.) demands: no data, no market (c) EUSJA
    Final round: Dino Trescher (r.) demands: no data, no market (c) EUSJA

    An overall wrap-up at the end of the nano debate was given by Menelaos Sotiriou, head of Science View Athens, organizer of science conferences and journalistic trainings in Greece, associated board member of the European Science Journalists EUSJA and its expert on EU projects. The debate in Kopenhagen showed that ”the public needs to be engaged from the early stages of research” he stated. Also young people and schools should be encouraged to particpate.

    The Horizon 2020 program of the EU will make funding for this type of public dialogue available. Furthermore he remarked that EUSJA is already partner of Nanodiode and will enhance the stakeholder engagement. Thus ”the public becomes a co-creator” of science, Sotiriou concluded.

     


    General Info:

    ESOF http://esof2014.org
    Nano Debate Announcement https://esof2014.pathable.com/#meetings/174652
    Press Release PRESS RELEASE_EUSJA Nano Science Debate@ESOF 2014
    Organizer: www.eusja.org
    Method Design: www.teli.de
    Debate Video: http://youtu.be/00gkJYYTWbA.
    Affiliation: http://www.nanodiode.eu/

    Nano Debate Structure & Schedule (75’’)
    Introduction & purpose (5’’)
    Stakeholder statements (5’’ each)
    Discussion at round tables in the audience (15’’)
    Presentation of questions, conclusion, concerns (3’’ each table)
    Feedback of the stakeholders (3’’ each)
    Wrapup, documentation, draft of a resolution/declaration (5’’)

    Links
    www.wissenschaftsdebatte.de (Online Platform German Science, mostly in German)
    http://www.wissenschaftsdebatte.de/?p=4847 (Presentation of format at PCST 2014 Salvador, Brazil, in English)
    http://www.maecenata.eu/images/documents/mi/resources/2013_op68.pdf (Manual, in German in English)
    http://euroscientist.com/2013/05/the-german-science-debate-innovation-with-democartic-participation (Euroscientist Report)

    Attachments:
    Written Stakeholder Statements & Powerpoint Presentations

    FINAL Stake Holder Statements ESOF Nano Debate
    ESOF_Lackinger.PPP
    ESOF Mikkelsen PPP
    ESOF Friedrichs PPP

     

     

  • Federation gears up for World Conference 2015 Seoul

    Federation GA Copenhagen 00113 years ago, EUSJA helped to create the World Federation of Science Journalists WCSJ. At the General Assembly, held during Euroscience Open Forum ESOF 2014 in Copenhagen, the offspring presented itself as a sturdy grown-up who is adapting to a rapidly changing media landscape.

    The Federation has set an historical landmark with its training programs (SCJOOP) for science journalists in Africa, Arabia and currently in Southeast Asia. Now, under the guidance of its new executive director Damien Chalaud, it is going to diversify its portfolio, run more activities, become more flexible and explore new funding streams. Training may involve not only journalists but also university teachers to communicate and disseminate their research broadly in the public. “Multiple entry points have become necessary”, explained Chalaud.

    Federation president Dr. Chul Joong Kim laid out the planning for the upcoming world conference in Seoul. It is scheduled next year from June 8 through June 12 and will be convened under the motto “Let’s expand our horizons”. Chul Joong Kim regretted a slow start, but now everything will fall into place. He promised that during the ESOF week the website will go online and that by November the program will be completed. Despite generous funding by the Korean government he could not yet oversee the budget and whether there will be enough money to help journalists with traveling aids and grants.Federation GA Copenhagen 005

    EUSJA president Satu Lipponen reported on last year’s world conference in Helsinki which she chaired. With 800 participants and a very attractive program it turned out a full success. She outlined that the 1st European Conference for Science Journalists -> https://www.eusja.org/past-meets-future-science-between-rock-women-hippy-power-report-1st-european-conference-for-sci-journs-ecsj, the  EUSJA strategy process and the reinvention drive -> https://www.eusja.org/mingling-changing-critical-together were a helpful outcome of the Helsinki world conference.

  • Past meets future. Science between rock, women, hippy power. Report 1st European Conference for Sci Journs ECSJ

    Past meets future. Science between rock, women, hippy power. Report 1st European Conference for Sci Journs ECSJ

    ECSJ organizer Jens Degett
    ECSJ organizer Jens Degett

    It was about time for such a conference, said moderator Quentin Cooper. The past met the future and opened science journalism new ways. The BBC journalist led through the very first European Conference for Science Journalists (ECSJ) on June 22, 2014. It was organized by the Danish Science Journalists’ Association DV and the European Science Journalists EUSJA. The event was sponsored by The Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, the Ministry of Higher Education and Science and the Otto Monsted Foundation.

    In her introduction, Ulla Margrethe Wewer, dean of the health faculty of the University of Copenhagen, described science and science journalism as a “love affair, not easy though, with two different languages”. But with married couples there is no routine either. Bridging science and science journalism “is a life long effort across two different culture”, she told the 200 attendees of ECSJ.

    European Science Journalists' Strategy
    European Science Journalists’ Strategy

    Jens Degett, DV president and main ECSJ organizer made a pledge for high standards in science journalism and warned that “informed ignorance is dangerous”. “Through a jungle of information science journalists have to find a way”, he told  the audience about the challenges of science journalism and: “Balance is not the solution” – which makes it even more difficult to report correctly on this topic, also given the fact that there is little pure science, but lots of different interests and conflict involved, as other speakers pointed out. Democracy requires “an informed public”, Degett reaffirmed.

    Journalists' Presidents: Chul Joong Kim, World Federation, Satu Lipponen, European Union
    Journalists’ Presidents: Chul Joong Kim, World Federation, Satu Lipponen, European Union

    EUSJA president Satu Lipponen reported on the strategy day -> https://www.eusja.org/mingling-changing-critical-together/. “We have to make more noise for our profession”, she urged the science journalists. The Finn does not want to be remembered as the head of a dying breed. The strategy process to reinvent and strengthen European Science Journalism will touch on many aspects of the profession such as develop new business models, promote better trainings, set up new membership rules, as tossed up by the participants of the strategy day on the ESOF Carlsberg site. The overall direction is, as displayed by the 2,5 meter high roll-up poster at Lipponen’s side: Changing. Critical. Together.

    “Try again, fail again, fail better” is the motto of two German science journalists who have ventured out to new models. Once employed by the renowned Financial Times Germany, Georg Dahm and Denis Dilba decided to set up “Substanz”, an only online science magazine, initially financed with 37 000 Euros raised with Krautfunding. The founders belong to a new generation, “digital natives”: “Print was yesterday, now we are in digital times which need to be fully developed”, the team said. “We don’t want to enter the rat race about the lastest news”, Dahm pointed out: There has been tons of news about new cancer treatments, “so why the …. do we still die off cancer?”, he asked.

    German Innovators Dahm & Dilba
    German Innovators Dahm & Dilba

    He described their operation as a “rock band on tour”, full of passion and reality. “We want to show science like it is, not clean labs, but full of action with the scientists in their cargo jeans and hairy legs”, Dahm said. The emphasis is on telling a unique story with unique elements, providing new layers of information and implementing a new choreography of text, pictures and design. -> http://www.startnext.de/substanz

    While Joost van Kasteren, head of the Dutch Science Journalists, reminded participants that good science journalism is a valuable “public good” and a pillar of democracy his Danish colleague Mette Dahlgaard demonstrated how this is being realized with her newspaper “Berlingske”. The publication has a team of investigative reporters who could prove that a breast cancer treatment was falsified. Her recommendations for related efforts:

    * Get all the documents (under the Freedom of Information Act)
    * ask politicians for help
    * meet your source face to face
    * ask the social communities and facebook for support,
    * JOIN FORCES.

    Investigative watchdog over democracy
    Investigative watchdog over democracy

    Curtis Brainard, Scientific American added examples from the United States about the “prevailing secrecy in corporate and governmental institutions” and despite of some success stories “access to information under the Obama administration has gotten worse”, he regretted.

    Another presentation touched on the gender question. How fair are women represented in science and science reporting? Ingrid Wünning Tschol, Bosch Foundation presented a new date base and platform which helps to find excellent female researchers -> http://www.academia-net.org/ as a consequence about complains that women were not represented on the ESOF board.

    Anita Frank Goth from KVINFO put Denmark under the magnifying glass and detected many gender flaws. In 2014, the media is still governed by men. They hold 80 percent of the positions. Expertise comes with age, said Goth, but: Women over 50 years have in Denmark a severe problem. They make up only 23 percent of the experts which go on TV screen on various scientific issues. “Shut up and stay beautiful”, the KVINFO spokesperson summed up the gender situation in Denmark, broadly hailed as a liberal, participative country with equal opportunities. ->  http://forside.kvinfo.dk

    Inclusion of women in Denmark -- work in progress
    Inclusion of women in Denmark — work in progress

    The 1st European Conference for Science Journalists ended with a reward ceremony. Jens Degett applauded Jacome Armas for a new format on science journalism which reaches the young people. Officially it’s called “science and cocktails”, more commonly “hippy science”.

    Armas explained why people between 20 and 40 are not interested in science. They had bad experience, “school sucks”, he explained. That’s why they want to party. All you need is to “deconstruct” the scheme, he said, integrate science into the party scene, discos, theatres. Christiania, Kopenhagen’s former hippy commune, provides innovative lecture platforms for scientists from all over the world: 50 events in 4,5 years, he reported, with audiences up to 450 people.

    Science & Cocktail (and beer) -- successor of  Café Scientifique
    Science & Cocktail (and beer) — successor of Café Scientifique

    The boring “café scientifique” is out, Armas proclaimed: Science and Cocktails is the new way to go! -> http://www.scienceandcocktails.org